While ARM is not perfect, it does allow companies like Apple more control over the secretive firmware that boots these chips.
While ARM is not perfect, it does allow companies like Apple more control over the secretive firmware that boots these chips.
To reduce that attack surface, Mac computers run a custom ME firmware from which the majority of components have been removed. … The primary use of the ME is audio and video copyright protection on Mac computers that have only Intel-based graphics.
https://support.apple.com/en-au/guide/security/seced055bcf6/...
Both AMD and ARM have something similar to Intel's ME. Let's not pretend this is by accident.
Alternatively, if you want to write your own TrustZone (for example on a RockChip CPU), you are free to write it and use it.
You can not run any firmware on an Intel or AMD chip that has not been signed by Intel ir AMD. All signed Intel firmware contains the Intel ME backdoor.
1. https://libreboot.org/faq.html#amd-platform-security-process...
2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trusted_execution_environment
There's an older subthread on this at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16081422 which also laments the lack of documentation on this.
After doing a bit of reading DMTF DASH appears to be implemented in the NIC from Broadcom or Realtek and uses the PCIE interface with the chipset from the NIC.
"To support out-of-band management, a client system typically requires a Network Controller that supports out-of-band management tasks, such as the Broadcom 5761." https://www.amd.com/system/files/documents/out-of-band-clien... (out-of-band management is the "it works while the machine is supposedly off" stuff)
But it also needs to talk to the system BIOS / UEFI, so I guess something else needs to be running as well? "DASH functionality requires a communication channel between the hardware platform features, system BIOS, and the Broadcom NetXtreme™ Gigabit Ethernet Controller." (http://h10032.www1.hp.com/ctg/Manual/c01944865). I mean, the PCIe interface is useless if the other end is actually off (and not just supposedly off).
https://docs.broadcom.com/doc/1211168563383
I presume it wakes up the chipset to do most of its work remotely.
It would make sense they want complete control over their hardware stack end to end. You can even see this in the Apple Secure Enclave on mobile, which was made possible due to their ability to customise their own ARM chips.