I've written and read a bunch of lisp and I'm slowly working my way through SICP at a leisurely pace, but I totally understand what these OP means. Some talk about lisp as something magical (it appears on xkcd as a sort of "god's programming language" - https://xkcd.com/224) yet often seem cagey about actually sharing exactly why they think so. A great example of what I mean is this pretty famous essay by pg: http://www.paulgraham.com/avg.html.
In fact he says "Lisp is so great not because of some magic quality visible only to devotees, but because it is simply the most powerful language available" - which seems to dispel the "magic" bit ... but then throws out the tantalising "most powerful language" without (in my opinion) giving a compelling argument. He mentions how lisp macros are more powerful than those in C and does say "Lisp code is made out of Lisp data objects" and a few other bits and pieces about how it was higher-level than other popular languages at the time (the mid-1990s). It certainly made me curious to explore the language, but definitely left me with unanswered questions.
My opinion is that this phenomenon is a result of a number of things, including:
1. some people went through a transformative experience through learning lisp, and are deliberately vague to entice others into exploring it without ruining some of the fun of self-discovery
2. some people had the same, but think that it's enough to declare these things and don't care if you believe them or not
3. some people parrot what they have read some smart folks say and simply can't formulate a good explanation even if they wanted to