I have another pet theory for coffee: habitual coffee drinkers are uncomfortable with the idea of it being a vice, and so they conduct study after study to highlight the benefits, thus rationalizing their consumption.
That one I'm keeping.
There might be some tiny fraction of coffee drinkers who spaz out about stuff like that, but they'd generally be the ones spazzing out about everything.
Then I see a lot of people doing both.
An irritated coffee drinker who has been told coffee can be harmful is going to have a whole lot more energy to produce a “counter study”.