If you define early web as pre-1998, then you’re essentially talking about five guys who all had computer science backgrounds. Yes, they were good at their jobs, but it was never going to last. Increasing the number of web developers by 1000x by definition had to drag down their average skill level to the average skill level of the population at large.

Most definitions of the early web include the PHP Cambrian explosion because essentially all websites today got their start then and only a few horseshoe crabs sites (mostly the homepages for CS profs!) predating it survive. Gopher sites were also probably really easy to scrape too. ;-)