Plastics are undeniably useful, but it does seem like the unforeseen consequences might be too large to ignore at this point. I just hope that it doesn't have neurological problems.
Plastics are undeniably useful, but it does seem like the unforeseen consequences might be too large to ignore at this point. I just hope that it doesn't have neurological problems.
Some plastics like PLA and PHA are highly unlikely to cause problems 50-100 years in the future because they don't last that long unless carefully preserved. California funded a study of how long it takes PLA and PHA to break down in the ocean and figured out that PHA is basically gone in six months while PLA will last about 3 years:
https://www2.calrecycle.ca.gov/Publications/Download/1006?op...
Plastic straw decomposition:
200 years [0]
Plastic bootle decomposition:
450 years [0]
PLA is a fraction of the world's plastic pollution. Mixing in this marginal example is misleading. We shouldn't downplay the decomposition time of _most_ plastics. Plastics and fossil fuel emissions are the asbestos of our time.
Single-use plastic, outside medical applications, should be banned worldwide.
[0] https://www.wwf.org.au/news/blogs/the-lifecycle-of-plastics
Can you expand on that? It's not the topic of the linked paper and DDG doesn't show much on a link between biodiversity collapse (a proven problem) and nanoplastics.
And what other terrible things might they cause?
Edit: Clearly I just gave the easiest example, not the most relevant one. A basic Google search points to [1], for instance, where you find observations such as
If algae and plankton communities are threatened, the entire food web may change. Animals that feed on algae and plankton, such as fish and turtles, will have less food. If populations of those animals decrease, there will be less food for apex predators such as tuna, sharks, and whales. Eventually, seafood becomes less available and more expensive for people.
These dangers are compounded by the fact that plastics both leach out and absorb harmful pollutants. As plastics break down through photodegradation, they leach out colorants and chemicals, such as bisphenol A (BPA), that have been linked to environmental and health problems. Conversely, plastics can also absorb pollutants, such as PCBs, from the seawater. These chemicals can then enter the food chain when consumed by marine life.
So, I frankly haven't carefully looked into the prospects of "biodiversity collapse", but even that stark term sounds justified. Surely another terrible thing, in any event.
[1] https://www.nationalgeographic.org/encyclopedia/great-pacifi...
Given that, why should we care about accidentally killing a few on the side?
Are you vegan?
You have to integrate over a period of time that includes the future, so it's impossible to tell (without a reliable oracle.)
the way I see it is it's much faster and easier to ruin something than to fix it.
It's irrational to assert that "unknown" risks are outweighed by known/"proven" benefits.
By definition, the risks are unknown.
For a reductio ad absurdum proof, imagine that microplastics kill you on contact. This would show up in the death statistics very quickly. So in practice we can say with confidence that the possible unknown harms don't include mortality effects above a certain level.
There's definitely room for effects that we'd consider to be serious like "reduces male sperm counts by 50% over decades of exposure" or "increases cancer rates by 100%", but it's certainly possible (indeed, the correct and rational way of approaching this problem) to attempt to bound the upper limit of harm based on what we should be able to detect.
Note, I'm not commenting on the object-level question of _whether_ the benefits outweigh the costs or whether this is known; I would like to see a citation for that as I've not seen such an analysis. I'm just addressing the meta-level question of if it's possible to know.