Writing, Reading, Writing
georgerrmartin.com
georgerrmartin.com
I simply don't trust GRM with finishing his saga. He prefers doing other things. Full stop. No insults, nothing illegal. But I won't buy anything else from him.
Neil was like 'he doesn't owe you anything'. But this was and is patently wrong.
We are not seeing TWOW since 9years and the prequels are written, edited and published. The GoT series is finished. the prequel series of night walkers is being announced and the writing has begun.
and we are still waiting for TWOW!
This is a breach in trust, if not anything else. Sure, he can choose to write or not write anything he wants, but readers are invested in the stories. and it wasn't until the pandemic struck that he actually started to write the books.
I just hope that he finishes ADOS too. That way, he'll be free to write whichever prequel he wishes too and we'll be able to read the next 2 books within a few years!
Look, if the story was not finished when you started to read, it was your decision, but the author is not obliged to do anything related to a book after publishing it. This is not the first, nor will be the last, story that is left unfinished, and it is not the end of the world. If you need an ending, imagine one! Once the story has been published, it is not solely the authors, you are free to plot and theorize and invent. If later on the author does something different, you did not win or lose anything if your endings match or not.
It is not a binding contract, yes. But it is an unwritten rule to finish the current work of art, don't you agree?
Sure, he is not breaking the law or anything like that. But it breaks the trust in the writer, or at least I think so.
The reason he is successful is because people read it.
Yes, we can imagine the ending. But it is not unfair to those who bought his books.
Do I want Jim Butcher to finish the Dresden Files? Oh my, yes. Do I think he owes me more books because I've read all the current ones? Absolutely not. I'll devour the new ones when they come out, but they are treats, luxuries, that I pay for. Jim Butcher owes me nothing.
GRRM owes the publisher a finished manuscript if he has an actual legal contract. But that's about it.
I never said there is a social contract. I said that he is breaching the trust in readers. The trust that made him rich and famous in the first place.
There is. People bought his first 5 books because he had promised he'd release the 6th and 7th book by 2019 and 2020. If they knew he'd never release them, they'd have not bought it.
He is rich and famous because we readers bought his books way before he was famous.
if millions wouldn't have bought his books, he'd not have been famous and you wouldn't come here to defend him.
We readers, collectively are owed a book, not personally. And the main issue which you ignore is that he is writing prequels upon prequels. That is the main problem I have.
Im sorry but that is ridiculous. People in general dont evaluate that when reading or recommending a book. When only 1 book was written, people read it, loved it and recommended it. As it was: 1 sole book. Not due to a plan to have 6 more books afterwards.
It is an epic saga which is broken across eight books.
This is not like 'not a penny more, not a penny less' which was a standalone book by Jeffrey Archer or 11.22.63, another standalone book by Stephen King.
I am not holding my breath out for 11.22.64 demanding that King write a sequel to it. No sir.
Why everyone is holding their breath for GoT is that it is an unfinished book which was announced as a 8part series.
> People in general dont evaluate that when reading or recommending a book.
LOL go talk to GoT fans. We've been waiting 11yrs for a sequel which was promised 8+yrs ago. Ask them what I said. 'Would you have read GoT if you knew that GRRM would rather write a prequel than finish the current series.'
I am pretty sure everyone will say NO.
I mentioned readers of the first book, not multi-year fans. Obviously those are already invested, you are biasing the sample. And you are changing the question.
Give me a freaking break. I think you are taking the sample of 1 (you) and then making this argument.
Every single person knew from the start that it is going to be a series. But if they knew that he'd not write any sequel for 11yrs but will keep on writing prequels for his HBO shows then nobody would have bothered to buy his book.
And which idiot will read the first GoT book and will be satisfied. "WOW this is a great book and I don't care if the sequel is ever written". The value of the story is in ALL the eight books and not in any of the standalone books.
Talking to you is a waste of time and I am not going to comment. But your logic was so atrocious that I had to reply. but not going to reply to you ever again.
sayoonara.
And you are changing the topic now that your point is demolished. Adios.
> When only 1 book was written, people read it, loved it and recommended it. As it was: 1 sole book.
You answered this:
> 'Would you have read GoT if you knew that GRRM would rather write a prequel than finish the current series.' I am pretty sure everyone will say NO.
Which doesn't make sense. When only the first book was written, people did not recommend the complete saga, and the value put on book #7 was close to 0. What they were recommending to colleagues, and reading by the thousands, was just the first book. If you reread what I said, I'm directly pointing to a counterexample to your reasoning that the saga is not interesting without book seven - because it was, back when it was 1 book, then when it was just 2, etc.
Anyway, adiós!
He himself has said that the last two books were actually one very-large-book. Truth be told, this is a series, so it more-or-less looks like one BIG story told over 8books.
That is why I said that you're absurdly and patently wrong.
Who taught you that you were entitled to more? Are you a patron, supporting his way of living, the way things were once upon a time? You would be entitled to the work, in that case. But things don't work that way now.
Neil was right.
It's not "another book". GoT is structured as a single, very large novel, divided in volumes, just like LOTR. There's no real ending to volumes, and somebody starting from the 5th book would understand little to nothing about the story.
I wouldn't require Frank Herbert to write the next Dune novel - most of them are quite self contained. The same would be true for most novels from Rowling so far; even though there's a "larger story" behind, books are self-contained (with the exception of the 6th HP book). If she quits writing Cormoran Strike novels, I wouldn't think she had breached my trust.
I bought (and spent time!) 5/7 of a novel (GoT) with the clear expectation that it would, someday, finish. And this expectation seems still to exist - the author never declared he's dropped the saga. It sometimes happens that a series gets interrupted because of low sales or other problems with the author (I can remember some comics - e.g. the Nana manga), but the GoT affair seems deliberate.
Would you keep reading (and buying) books if you knew you couldn't finish them? Would you play (and buy) videogames that you couldn't finish? There's a kind of "trust system" that makes me buy unfinished things. If a large series, especially an extra-successful one, where money is not the problem, doesn't finish, there's a breach of trust.
Everything IMHO. And I'd never send any kind of threat to GRRM. But I won't buy anything else from him, or at least anything unfinished.
Exactly. And I am in the same boat as you. I don't send him hate email or death threats, but I ain't going to buy another book of his or watch another TV show until he finishes writing this series.
First of all, please watch your tone and words. You do not feed me, neither do you give me pocket money. I won't tolerate this holier-than-thou attitude from anyone apart from those who directly pay me money for survival or feed me.
> Are you a patron
Yes, I (along with millions) bought his books before it was turned into a series, thus making him famous. He'd have been yet another failed author if we hadn't bought his books before he was famous.
> supporting his way of living
Yeah, millions of people like me bought his book when he wasn't famous, that's the reason he got famous. So we are supporting his way of living. He'd have been yet another failed author if we hadn't bought his books before he was famous.
If we hadn't bought his books, he wouldn't have become famous. His books would have flopped and he wouldn't have gotten the HBO contract.
Do you see the irony of your message?
I am not 'entitled' to his work. I don't abuse him online. Neither do I send him hate mail saying 'GIVE ME THE BOOK'.
But I am disappointed that he is not following the unwritten contract of not starting work on a new work without finishing the promised work.
You are being quite rude just like Neil. You think that an author can announced 2 books are pending and not work on it for 11yrs and readers should just suck it.
This isn't a one off book like what Archer/Deaver writes. IN that case, I would not expect them to write another book. But this was said to be an epic fantasy with 10 books.
Of course readers will expect.
But the issue isn't that he is writing slow. As a writer, I more than understand that. The issue is, he is writing prequels upon prequels while it seems as if he has abandoned the original books. he is on record saying 'just like LoTR was not JRRM's main work. GoT isn't mine'
If he had said so 11yrs ago, I wouldn't have wasted money buying all his books. as would a million others. then he wouldn't have become famous and we wouldn't be having this conversation in the first place.
That being said, I do not like the online hate against him for not finishing the book. I am just privately sad that he is not following his unwritten contract. Of course he doesn't owe anything to me personally. But he does owe to the readers who made him famous.
I'm still happy that I got to read them. Maybe there is less sunk-cost-fallacy given I didn't pay for them.
But it's still a given that sometimes, people just die, or move on.
He had been busy with the TV series and other things. With the pandemic raging, I don't think he'll be super busy with Hollywood.
Also, this might be an unpopular opinion, but I am grateful that he did not complete his series. Hear me out first!
When I first read The Game of Thrones, it was an ebook. I immediately bought the paperback set, only to realise a few months later that the series is not complete. (yes, I never google because ages ago, I was reading a Dan Brown book, and I accidentally ruined it for me by reading out what happens in the end).
After finishing the last book, I was stunned. No, I have read LoTR, but ASOIAF was unlike anything I have ever read, including the Mahabharata (which, is much more complex and originally written as Sanskrit verses).
But, that gave me motivation to finally start writing novels. I am not a famous author just yet. I have been writing consistently for the last six years, and I have published only one short story on Kindle a few weeks ago.
I find that GRRM has encouraged a lot of writers to write. The first thing I did when I started to write was to read his advice for new authors and it was great. His #1 advice is 'stop writing in my universe or Star wars universe of JRR's universe. Creating characters and world building is a significant part of story telling and you will not be an author until you do so. otherwise you are just writing fan fiction'
That month, I wrote my first short story. Then my first short film script which won the silver script award in India Film Project 2007.
Since then, I have written four full length novels. I am currently working on my fifth novel.
And all this has been because GoT's next book isn't coming out and I was so frustrated about that, that I started writing my own novels. (I know it does not sound logic, but that's how I felt. Damn it, I'm writing my own novels!)