The Tragedy of the New Coronavirus Spikes
newyorker.com
newyorker.com
https://spectator.us/where-deaths-coronavirus-wave/
They both overstate their respective cases.
I also would toss this one into the mix, “CDC Now Estimates there have been over 20 million Coronavirus cases”;
https://outkick.com/cdc-now-estimates-there-have-been-over-2...
The upshot is that this article could more accurately be titled Where’s the tragedy of the new Coronavirus spikes?. Strip away the politics and we have a huge uptick in case with in some cases the lowest death rates we’ve seen since March.
The media keeps loosing the message in the midst of the disaster porn and political finger-pointing. We need the economy to be open to the absolute greatest extent possible while hospital capacity remains near maximum. The long-term damage (in dollars and lives) in over-regulating the extent of the lockdown could exceed the damage of COVID by an order magnitude.
Needless to say, the more cases we can shift forward into summer and fall, versus having to deal with those cases in winter concomitant with flu season is how we prevent the disaster of a second wave. Hospitals in winter can be overwhelmed by a bad flu season alone, and COVID didn’t go exponential until after flu had tapered this year. We do not want to see them peaking together in vulnerable populations.
This drumbeat of articles like this just totally miss the point entirely, as if we could just keep handing out trillions of dollars a month indefinitely until a half billion doses of vaccine are ready to go, and as if even if we did that we’re not inadvertently causing hundreds of thousands of death due to side effects of quarantine and things like canceled elective procedures.
A lot has changed over the last couple months, but the media is still “reporting” like it’s February.
As usual, it is an argument about the behaviour of people and the press on the opposite side of the political spectrum, like every damn discussion in America is about.
Some of the points are valid, but it's hard to take the article seriously when it clearly has a political agenda. It's main thesis is that there isn't an uptick in deaths, so this is a good thing. It doesn't talk about the death rate in absolute terms and whether that is acceptable. It doesn't model the economic impact of lock down on future deaths. It also misses the obvious point that the death rate lags around 3 weeks behind the cases, because that is how long the virus takes to kill.
There are valid discussions to be had about the economic and human costs of lock down, the worth of human life. In europe the places that locked down hard and early have the virus under far better control and were able to open up their economies with safety measures in place earlier than those that have had to deal with the cost of locking down late. If you look at the number of cases in the US, it is clearly taking off again, and is at a rate higher than the peak in April [1].
We are absolutely seeing an uptick in cases. Compared to early April we are also testing a lot more, and I’m not sure that the average positivity rate across the US is higher now than it was, e.g. April 1, but at a local level there are definitely places where this is true. Certainly positivity rate has increased dramatically since, e.g. June 1 in many places. We don’t see a concomitant increase in death rates because most cases must be in the 20-30 yrs age range, probably due to that age range predominantly being the ones going out in large groups over the last month.
I think everyone is looking for the right balance of policies that minimizes overall suffering and loss of life. I’m not sure which European countries you would consider having locked down “early” rather than “late”. The decision to open economies at this point seems purely a political one and no longer based on objective facts like hospital capacity.
I think the simple fact is the US saw a surge over the last month because millions of young adults held truly massive rallies. If rallies subside or the population becomes substantially infected and then immune, case counts will fall rapidly. That age range is largely unaffected by SARS-CoV-2 and the US doesn’t have a large number of multi-generational households, so luckily I think the case counts amount to a lot of smoke with little fire.
The lowest death rate first of all is still very high, and secondly, it is because the demographic has shifted towards younger population. It will go up back soon.
The best thing to do now is a) universal masking; b) close the businesses, causing biggest trouble, such as bars.
Herd immunity is not binary, it’s a spectrum. Every person walking around with antibodies suppresses the R factor that much more. IMO this is a big reason new cases have been so low in NYC - so many people walking around with immunity it’s now highly suppressed.
> I also keep hearing about "hundreds of thousands of death due to side effects of quarantine" and have not seen a single reputable study regarding that.
Well, for example, the NY Times reported about 1/3 of excess deaths in NY were due to quarantine;
https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/06/01/us/coronaviru...
And that’s just the immediate effects of quarantine. The long-term effects are actually worse.
Speaking of bars - just switch the news channel on, all the latest outbrakes are from bars and nightclubs. And that would be considered science by the way, just not made by degreed scientists. Unless of course someone is a conspiracy theorist, and distrust the local news when they go to some bar in Michigan, to make a report about a closure.
You really just download your opinions from the top 10 results on Google and whatever the anchor person tells you? Fascinating.
As for scientists, they do not agree on this point at all. The virus is nanometers thick and can easily sail through the vast majority of facial coverings people are using. It also easily becomes useless when worn for long periods of time, or when adjusting the mask with your hand or when eating or drinking, etc.
How much of the outbreaks are attributed to the massive gatherings and protests of people over the past few weeks? Why are bars blamed for this?
When I google something, I of course check only trustworthy sources such as CDC, Lancet, NHS etc. And they happen to come first by the way.
Of course it can pass through. It does not to protect you mostly, it protects the others from your droplets, and also dramatically lowers the speed and momentum of the air and viral particles, because of air friction in the layers of textile. As the result, the particles do not fly too far from your mouth.
Yes you are right, if you misuse, they become less useful for you personally; therefore do not adjust them with dirty hands, and change every 2 hours, as I do. Still, even misused mask prevents the others from you exhaled air and droplets.
One thing though I agree with that gatherings (be it BLM or Trumps rallies) were harmful and probably more than bars. But they are already the past. Right now we need to think about the present.
I know I read an article as the protests went on that said, "if we don't see an uptick in cases a couple of weeks from now, we need to re-evaluate what we know about the virus" and, more recently, I see articles that say, "there haven't been upticks in the virus due to the mass protests."
Which leads me to conclude: 1) there is something we don't understand about the virus, 2) there is something we don't understand about the protests or protesters, or 3) the articles are not congruent with the real situation.
Explanations might include: the virus doesn't transmit well outdoors; the protesters were in a demographic that didn't get or didn't notice getting the disease; the protesters have not been tested for the disease; the disease was not present at the protests; the reporter didn't have the facts; or, the reporter did not report facts because of some countering (most likely political) belief.
I'm still perplexed about this. Wouldn't mind flexing some data science muscles but I don't have the time and my skills aren't up to snuff. If anyone has some clarity, please share!
https://img.apmcdn.org/6b486323329122674a9b5fbfdcf2e51f9ad83...
IMO it’s unquestionable that mass protests contributed to the spread of COVID, it’s just apparently uncouth to say so.
It may be true that during daylight hours outside, being outside on a sunny day the UV dampens the virus. But we know that the virus mostly doesn’t transmit on surfaces it transmits in suspended droplets. It also can be absorbed through the eyes not just nasal passages. Certainly evening mass protests with people in close proximity absolutely spreads COVID. I don’t think anyone can seriously argue otherwise.
All else being equal, having everyone wear a mask versus not probably reduces the R value at least somewhat, but this is assuming wearing masks doesn’t also lead to an increase in risky behavior. If people wearing a mask feel they are less likely to get or spread COVID and therefore alter their behavior, then that new behavior works to some extent to either partially nullify, or even completely nullify any benefit or conceivably makes matters worse.
But frankly this mask discussion misses the forest for the trees. Somehow we went from “flatten the curve” to “minimize all cases” to “shutdown everything until it’s gone”. We cannot continue to shutdown everything, we’ve already paid about $10 trillion trying to do that for just a few months and now have 40 million unemployed.
People who feel they are vulnerable should be provided the support and services they need to protect themselves and avoid exposure. Stricter policies should reinforce these protections for the most vulnerable populations, like nursing home visitation and screening employees in contact with the elderly. The IFR is so massively skewed to the elderly, we need to be 100% focused on protecting that population. For those under 70 the quarantine “cure” is worse than the disease.
I wish that graph showed absolute numbers instead of percents, but it is very nice as it is. Interesting points to ponder.
Could this change in social distancing, hygiene habits i.e. Hand-washing frequency, use of desinfectants on hands, public surfaces, parcels, shopping trolleys, etc. could this create a positive pressure on flu viruses promoting a particularly virulent flu in seasons to come?
Could the measures used to contain this pandemic provide the selection pressure conditions for a future (worse?) flu pandemic?
edit:typo
Many a new (to humans) disease has started off unusually deadly, only to evolve to keep its host alive longer to help further its spread.
https://img.apmcdn.org/6b486323329122674a9b5fbfdcf2e51f9ad83...
The younger demographic happens to be vanishingly unlikely to die, and highly unlikely to even be hospitalized, from a case of SARS-CoV-2.
Deaths within days of detection are fairly unusual.
Also, the average age of cases has generally fallen (presumably older people are being more careful than younger people) and younger people are less likely to die.
But the current guesses are that the most vulnerable people already died, and less usage of ventilators or more steroids have better outcomes.
My personal guess is that our testing methods still don't work reliably most of the time, since the Santa Clara dashboard has extremely low positives (2.86%) considering we had direct flights from Wuhan (and Shanghai) for 2 months after the first hospitalization, and indirect flights after that until even more recently.
I mean, come on - one of the most contagious diseases, but only 3% positive?
If nobody wants to save then by definition whatever is spent will be collected by tax.
Perhaps read The Deficit Myth by Stephanie Kelton to understand how that works
Hopefully you don't soon find out!
*one week moving average
Wow, 50%. Sounds yuuge!
Oh wait, that's a couple dozen people?