That seems like an /extremely/ dubious assertion. Maybe it's counter-intuitive and correct? Anything to back it?
That seems like an /extremely/ dubious assertion. Maybe it's counter-intuitive and correct? Anything to back it?
It is described here in the top section
So that's a very, very much weaker claim "time outside may affect ..." and acknowledges the role of genetics and other factors. Of those 2 references I looked at https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5599950/
I declare I have no expertise in the field but also didn't find the meta-analysis paper convincing.
This one: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26372583/
Looks the most promising. I couldn't find a replication.
So there could be something in "time outside" as a beneficial preventative measure for some children w.r.t. myopia. There is nothing much like "Myopia is caused by insufficient bright light as a child" as I understand that sentence. But maybe I've misunderstood?
Any explanation of myopia must explain why it is far more prevalent now. Genetics does not explain that.
(Now we've had the relevant part of the conversation will you please humour me as I whinge like a 3 y.o. about how much it s&%ts me on some of the days I can't see straight? Good. Thanks. As you were...)
https://www.nature.com/news/the-myopia-boom-1.17120
> East Asia has been gripped by an unprecedented rise in myopia, also known as short-sightedness. Sixty years ago, 10–20% of the Chinese population was short-sighted. Today, up to 90% of teenagers and young adults are. In Seoul, a whopping 96.5% of 19-year-old men are short-sighted.
I don't know how that change is possible in one generation if genetics are to blame. It's possible I'm missing something though.
Is it certain that we are comparing like for like? Many more people everywhere do work that requires a lot of reading now than 60 years ago even in the northern Europe so perhaps myopia is more often diagnosed now simply because it is more of a problem in the modern environment.
Sure, you have to be worried about selection biases of all sorts including survivorship bias (eg. suppose myopic people mostly died before they reached 50), but in general, if myopia is as high or higher among 20yo than 60yo today, it tells you something pretty darn significant.