I agree with your frustrations around this limitation and think file watchers should do their best to support arbitrary file addition/removal in directories. That being said, the races do matter when you edit with "mammal speed" but use source control to merge/rebase commits that affect your watched directories. Especially in a team setting when multiple coworkers are working on the same directories, git can be blasting rapidly through a lot of file moves, deletions etc so it's not really an edge case.