Court Rules Facebook Widgets Can Be Considered Wiretaps
gizmodo.com
gizmodo.com
Also interesting that Facebook is the bad guy here instead of the actual side owner including the widget. I mean without everyone including those scripts on their side, Facebook did not have the opportunity to receive such information.
The contention here is that adding surreptitious tracking code to this utility script amounts to illegal electronic surveillance (“wiretapping”), the same as if you had given someone a painting with a secret microphone and transmitter inside.
Isn't this true for most advertising code as well? And how about Google Analytics? Or Stripe, which records mouse movements in order to fight fraud [1]?
Yes. Which is exactly why this ruling is interesting.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Thing_(listening_device)
Not exactly a painting but this case got some fame.
Facebook is doing the wiretapping, not the site owner.
Perhaps you are suggesting that the plaintiffs could allege a conspiracy to commit wiretapping?
These cases never succeed because the damages are too speculative. What injury/harm have the plaintiffs suffered as a result of the wiretapping? How can that be quantified?
Calling this piece journalism is overly charitable.
Here’s the source article, minus the snark and misinterpreted facts: https://www.mediapost.com/publications/article/353072/facebo...
To circumvent this problem they developed a kind of wrapper around those widgets that won't load the widget (which will than of course inevitably trigger transfer of personal data to the social network in question) until explicitly clicked by the user. This solution was than published under an open-source license so it can be used by any interested webmaster. It's called "Heise Shariff" and can be found on GitHub [1].
Edit: Edited link
Maybe this? [0].