Downvotes are good for BAD COMMENTS. Things which do not add constructively to a discussion.
If someone DISAGREES however, that is what a reply beneath stating the disagreement is for.
Downvotes are good for BAD COMMENTS. Things which do not add constructively to a discussion.
If someone DISAGREES however, that is what a reply beneath stating the disagreement is for.
I know I'm not a troll, so obviously if someone downvotes me it's because they disagree and therefore unfair. But maybe not from their perspective.
You can also downvote and reply; I don't know how common that is. But given the number of people who say they don't know why they are downvoted, it seems to me like a reasonable thing to do.
Would be cool if "downvote"(for relevance)and "disagree" would be mutually exclusive (either/or).
You either decide this post is not relevant to the discussion at all or you disagree with the argument.
"Upvote" for relevance and "disagree" could be combined.
You decide this post is relevant to the discussion but you disagree with the argument.
Of course everything depends on users using the tools in good faith. But it would be an interesting approach to decouple "downvoting" from "disagreement".