It's a really bad look on Google's part to be pushing this.
It's a really bad look on Google's part to be pushing this.
And it appears to be a problem.
Another problem is, there's effectively no distinction between regulator and regulatee.
If they do that, it's not really visible, I don't see any regulation with how Google is behaving regarding search & web, if anything it looks like anti-competitive monopoly behaviours.
Self-regulating in the same way an alcoholic meth addict self-regulates.
Yes, AMP is an anti-competitive move by Google
At the same time AMP is "faster" because it gets rid of all the nagware and JS crap that the original page has.
So yeah, I don't like what Google is doing but I don't like what NYT is doing neither
Google gives preference to AMP content whether the source page is lightning fast or not. I get the frustration with crappy web pages, but a big part of the reason web pages are getting increasingly crappy is because Google and Facebook (and to a much lessor extent Amazon in a weird way) have a stranglehold on the web advertising market and publishers are getting smaller and smaller slices of advertising revenue. AMP increases Google's lock on the market. Since AMP pages can only really be monetized by the publisher, this puts even more power in Google's hands.
So you can see why there must be some kind of internal struggle at Google. They understand the value of a faster web but they also cannot go after the main cause of the slow web. And this is how technology such as AMP gets invented and makes things worse.
It’s been one of the primary things that’s driven me away from google and into DDG. I don’t really care about privacy enough to leave google, but I end up leaving more and more of their services because their competition is just less annoying.
(Albeit, that’s far more blockable)
AMP is faster only for poorly-optimized JS-heavy pages but the design is fundamentally flawed to require all of its own large amount of JavaScript to run before anything displays, whereas most of the traditional bloat doesn’t block rendering. That means any optimized page - Washington Post, NYT, etc. – loads noticeably faster even before you factor in how often you need to wait for AMP to load, realize that some part of the content is missing, and then wait for the real page to load anyway.
That design forces it to be less reliable, too: before I stopped using Google on mobile to avoid AMP, I would see on a near-daily basis failed page loads due to the AMP JS failing in some way and when it wasn’t failing it was still notably slow (5+ seconds or worse on LTE). Since all of that JavaScript is forced into the critical path, anything less than unrealistically high cache rates means the experience is worse than a normal web page.
WPT examples:
https://www.webpagetest.org/result/200704_GR_62165b7f695e300...
https://www.webpagetest.org/result/200704_5F_f5c36a7c41cf4c2...
AMP’s design is very fragile: if you are using Google search results, they correctly guess what you’re going to tap on before you do and your browser fully preloads it, it _might_ be faster to run all of that JavaScript before anything is allowed to load and render. If any part of that chain fails, it will almost certainly be slower or, because it disables standard browser behavior, prevent you from seeing content at all.
It is. AMP results load instantly for me.
> you would find it educational to learn about the issues with detecting user intent, reliably prefetching dependencies, and the relatively small / frequently purged caches on mobile browsers.
And you might find it educational to learn why AMP doesn't rely on these things. There are no dependencies that need to be fetched for the initial render.
This idea isn't surprising. Multiple other systems use the same ideas, including Apple News, many RSS readers, and Facebook Instant Articles. AMP just does it in a way that isn't anti-competitive (like the former) and allows for multiple monetization schemes and rich formatting (unlike RSS).
> if you are using Google search results, they correctly guess what you’re going to tap on before you do and your browser fully preloads it, it _might_ be faster to run all of that JavaScript before anything is allowed to load and render
AMP doesn't rely on fully prerendering the page, only the portion above the fold, which it can calculate because the link aggregator page knows the display size, and the elements allowed in AMP are required to report their dimensions. This allows multiple pages to be prerendered.
> because it disables standard browser behavior,
What standard browser behavior does it disable?
I'm confused, you make it sound like a free CDN is somehow a bad thing. You do realize people actually pay money to have their content on a CDN. I don't think Bing makes money on their AMP cache, and doubt they would want or even allow Google to link to content on their AMP cache...
The point of AMP cache is for Google (and Bing) to waste money making content faster for their users, in the hope that the user will then spend more time on search so they see more ads. The cache itself has nothing to do with the monopoly, and the fact that Bing can use AMP at all (since its open source) to get the same benefits actually shows the exact opposite.
That's nonsensical. That would reveal what the person searched for to a third party (Microsoft) even if they don't click on any results. The AMP Cache has to be controlled by the link aggregator in order to support safe prerendering, so Bing's AMP cache is used to prerender Bing results, and Google's AMP cache is used to prerender Google results. Compare to directly integrating with Google, in which case, Bing wouldn't get to take advantage of prerendering. The latter (the Apple News setup) is anti-competitive. AMP is not.