How would you tax a company that patents something it develops and sells itself? If the products/service they sell involves lots of non-patented features and/or multiple patented features, how do you determine the value of any individual patent?
How do you determine the value of patents effectively licensed through an Agreement Not-to-Sue?
For normal ip it would likely need to get registered in order to receive copyright protection. This way creators only pay taxes for their larger works. The biggest problem with this is that this tilts the playing field against smaller creators.
A possible solution could involve letting the patent owner itself state how valuable owning the patent is to them. They could declare a monetary number X and then do annual payments of say 0.1% of that number. They could adjust the number monthly by statement to the patent office, but would have to pay the tax on the maximum number they told to the patent office within each year. Now comes the core of the idea: the number would be public, and any entity could "free" the patent by paying that amount X to the patent office which then redirects it to the patent's owners after deducting a tax. The patent would then enter the public domain.
So company A invents something, patents it, and claims a billion dollars of value to the patent office. They have to pay a million in taxes annually. Company B thinks it could make a lot more than a billion dollars if the patent got lifted, and pays 1 billion to get rid of the patent. Company A is now 1 billion richer (minus patent freedom taxes), but now has to deal with competitors. So their next patent will have 10 billion as value number.
I'm not sure the idea is good or not, it has some problems, e.g. it might lead to patents becoming even larger than they are today so that they get lots of valuable stuff into the patent's umbrella. Patent offices might become more willing to grant patents for things as they are now a major revenue source for the government, and many patents on promising stuff will need big investors so that they can afford the taxes until the patent matures. Also companies won't be able to plan as well as they are now. Making the tax progressive will help with some of these problems, but maybe not enough and maybe not with all of them.
In many industries, a new/small company would never be able to price it’s patents out of the reach of its largest competitors, it would put them in the position of either spending huge amounts of their working capital in taxes to defend their patents, or let the patents be sold and compete with their large competitors on production, logistic, and support costs (which is a loosing position for a new small/new company).
It would be even worse in the case of a solo inventor. Imagine you come up with an idea so good it’s clearly worth a billion dollars, but only in an industry with a single, or small number, of big players. If that one big player, or several big players collectively, refuse to buy or license your patent, you won’t be able to afford the taxes and end up with nothing once it expires (and they are free to use it). If you want to try to develop it yourself, you now need to find a huge amount of additional investment just to cover the taxes.
does this actually happen in practise?
If the invention is clearly worth billions (that is, either it is capable of generating billions in value, or save costs of billions in value), then why wouldn't the big players license it?
If these big players openly collude (via contractual agreements for example), then it sounds illegal (or should be).
If these players aren't colluding per se, but "individually" decide to not purchase a license, then the first player that buys the license gets a head-start in their savings/rewards from using the patent.
That's easy. Have a flat fee per patent that increases based on years plus number of patents the company holds up to crazy amounts. What this does is three fold: 1) Tax patents the same way physical possessions are taxed. 2) Limit big corporations that have the budget to realize tons of patents quickly so patents are again used for the benefit of the small players. 3) Prevent patent trolls from holding big portfolios of bad patents as the costs would be extremely hard for them to maintain.
I think if everyone could freely build upon ideas, corporations wouldn't suddenly be making all of these amazing products that thwart every little player out there. Or rather, any more than they already do. And then we'd all be reaping the benefits of collective knowledge.
There are many other industries where advancement is not made without huge amounts of investment, and the only thing that protects the little players are patents. An industry like Chemical Engineering and Manufacture for example – the development of a new useful chemical compound may cost 10s of millions of dollars in research, testing, process improvements, etc. Why would any company bear that cost if they could just wait for another company to do it and start producing it themselves, undercutting the cost of the original developers who must price their offering higher to recuperate their R&D cost? What would stop any large manufacture from taking a novel new compound developed by a smaller competitor, or recent entrant, and using their large already existing production and logistics capacity to undercut their small competitor?
Also, regarding collective knowledge -- remember that the only alternative to patent protection is to keep something a trade secret. That encourages a company to never publicly disclose anything about their process that they can keep secret, which can theoretically be done forever, and can mean that when the company eventually ceases to exist, that knowledge can be lost.
I’m not saying that the patent system doesn’t have its flaws, and really needs some revisions and updates in places, but it does provide a real value.
Excuse me, this works the other way around, especially around communities like 3D printing that rely on players sharing information freely with each other.
Open hardware is threatened by patent holders, big or small.
I’m not saying that the patent system doesn’t have its flaws, and really needs some revisions and updates in places, but it does provide a real value.
You provided logical reasons as to why X and Y things happen this way, but not evidence that it actually happened this way in the world.
I would also argue that those two areas have a relatively low-cost of entry like software development, but only have such due to the huge amount of investment previously put into those fields, and existing industries around them. High-power and low-cost microchips, high efficiency stepper motors, etc, were developed due to decades of constant industry investment, and the open-hardware community isn’t going to be mass producing stepper-motors, microprocessors, or FPGAs anytime soon.
To be clear, these are both communities I think are great, and consider myself part of, but you can’t ignore the reality of the industrial and business world around them because it’s inconvenient. In an ideal world, everything would work like those communities, but our world is far, far, from ideal.
As for case examples for my arguments. For small player protection -- just look at how lack of patent enforcement causes so many small companies to fail due to lower-cost knockoffs produced in china being released before their brand gains traction. For the need for a return on investment -- that’s just how industry at large works. No company will invest significant funds developing something if there isn’t a reasonable chance of making a return on that investment. If all your competitors can immediately copy and undercut you, the ROI drops to zero. I can actually provide some specific examples from the company I work for / industry I work in, but I'd prefer to move the conversation offline if you'd like to discuses that.
As soon as the patents started expiring, it took less than a decade for the market size to grow by four orders of magnitude, part quality improved by an order of magnitude, part cost and machine cost dropped by three orders of magnitude. Everyone, including the fuckers that kept the market locked up, are benefiting massively from this. The innovations that enabled the dramatic development of the field over the past decade were primarily driven by a loose community of individual contributors and companies of all sizes, and there seems to be enough of a market for all those entities to exist simultaneously. You have mega-corps trivially reimplementing open innovation, and then failing commercially because everyone hates them and doesn't trust them enough to work with them. Patents are actively harmful to this industry.
As for open hardware producing capital investment intensive products, just have a look at what's happening in the RISC-V community. You can ensure return on investment by collaboration from the start - investing in an ecosystem rather than a particular product. It's much easier for smaller players to survive as part of an interwoven ecosystem than on their own with litigation as their only weapon. If the only way to get people to work with you is to threaten to sue them, you're going to be destroyed as soon as someone comes along with a bigger gun. The very concept of "protecting your investment" and treating everyone else as a competitor and a threat is a mindset that ends up self-fulfilling.
I would argue that many more companies get killed by hostile patent enforcement than by lack of patent enforcement.
You’re also still ignoring that 3D printing and Open Hardware would not exist without the trillions of dollars in capital investment made in all the underlying technologies. Investments that would have been an insanely risky propositions without IP protections.
Can you explain how the multi-billion/trillion-dollar research and development in jet engine design, commercial refrigeration, medical devices, drugs, microcircuit manufacturing, industrial mechatronics, etc, can be accomplished by the private sector, without legal protection to allow for a ROI? Can you find an example of someone developing Open Hardware who is making large enough profits to build their own semiconductor R&D labs and foundries?
And again, I’m not saying that there aren’t a lot of problems with patents. I fully agree there are. As you said, “hostile patent enforcement” (meaning forcing a company to defend itself against vague and often entirely invalid patents), is a serious problem. But that’s an argument for patent reform, not abolishment. Unless you can come up with an alternative way to protect the huge-to-astronomical R&D investments many industries require.
Also, to be blunt, thinking that “mega-corps trivially reimplementing open innovation, and then failing commercially because everyone hates them and doesn't trust them enough to work with them” applies to anything outside tiny niche and industry-internal markets is frankly silly. The general public will buy the next shiny new toy from whichever mega-corp has the best marketing. Serious industrial operations always prefer to buy from bigger companies as it reduces various sources of complexity and risk (this is an area I know firsthand and can go into detail on). It’s very rare that anyone cares who originally invented the technology. And regarding your last point -- without patent enforcement, no small company developing a functionally better technology would even exist to be attacked. Nobody would invest in starting a company if there was no way to stop the incumbent from reverse-engineering the improved tech before the start-up gained any market traction, adding it to their products, and crushing competition through price, marketing, and existing consumer network (again something I can talk about firsthand if you'd like to continue this off HN).
The 3D printing industry is a side effect of existing stuff developed for entirely unrelated purposes. There's nothing exciting there technically. The only reason it didn't go mainstream decades ago is patents. There was never any heavy capital investment in the underlying technologies - it's just yet another application of motion control, material handling, and CNC technology, which was never developed specifically for that, but taken into use after it was already widely adopted in other industries. Claiming it would never have existed without heavy capital investment is true, but misleading. It's like saying flexible PCBs and space blankets would never have existed without the moon landing. It's true, but now that the technology exists it's possible to use it without starting your own space program. There's plenty of money to be made and new stuff to be developed by standing on the shoulders of out-of-patent giants. 3D printing has a low cost of entry now - it didn't before. The cost of entry advantage came due to community/ecosystem based development, after the patents expired. Prior to that, it was much more expensive. This can definitely be replicated to other industries (and we're seeing it right now with computer peripherals for example).
There's an enormous number of industries with an ecosystem of specialized suppliers, some of which are tiny. The automotive industry is a prime example, where the big brands rely on thousands of tiny specialized vendors, many with single digit number of employees, for parts. The electronics industry is even more extremely so, with thousands of fabless semiconductor outfits with double digit employees, hundreds of packaging and testing companies serving those, thousands of distribution, assembly, and logistics companies on top of those, many one person or one family operations. The big foundries are what everyone knows, but none of them would exist without this. And the industry giants don't rely on patents because patents are not really safe to rely on - they mostly use trade secrets - both in the automotive and the electronics industries. You also see trade secrets as the core investment protection mechanism in aerospace, heavy industry (metallurgy, polymers, large-scale manufacturing processes) and related areas. Almost all heavily centralized industries except pharma/biotech rely on trade secrets rather than patents.
Industry-internal markets are where the bulk of the market for technology is. And reputation is critically important there. You definitely see large companies attempt to break into these ecosystem based markets and fail commercially because they don't give a shit about their customers, and smaller outfits do. And there's certainly aversion to dealing with litigation-trigger-happy outfits. I see a whole lot of migration away from products after Oracle acquisitions for example.
And fuck the idea that no innovative companies would exist without patents. There's endless companies that don't have patents, and exist, and take investment. And there's countless instances of companies that do have patents being attacked by megacorps who want to take their stuff, and of course the megacorp almost always gets away with it because they have the bigger guns, and can spend years in litigation until the victim folds and they can buy their assets at pennies to the dollar. Patents have never been adequate protection for a small company. They mostly exist to justify investment, rather than to reduce risk.
I don't see a way to reform patents that makes them a net gain to humanity. I see them doing a whole lot of damage now. I don't see a moral justification for this to go on.
A solution to address that might be in the form of designed profits, where the exclusivity period is determined by the profits generated. However I'd also still like to see second and more sources, so a compulsory license during this period is also desirable, but might focus on a fixed percentage of profits. (Also contributing to paying down the public liberation fee of the work.)
For example, someone wants to patent "one click shopping". The USPTO publishes the "objective" section of the patent application. Then, during the challenge-period, someone else reads the application, implements a one-click shopping button, sends the solution to the USPTO and the patent is denied. Optionally, the person who found the solution (either by implementation or by finding prior art) is then compensated for their work by the original applicant.
The system could be extended by allowing the patent applicant to specify the expiration date for the patent, but a longer expiration time will also mean that the challenge-period will be longer and the cost for a rebuttal will be higher.
You still get a huge market share/reputation and likely can keep that by being the first to market which is enough reward imo to a product to market.
If the public did subsidize any ip then that ip should be disimenated after the subsidy period to the public.
That doesn't seem to be true of anything else covered by patents. Software is cheap to develop, and other kinds of engineered products (cars, hardware, etc.) usually aren't that much cheaper to reproduce than they are to develop.
I think patents should simply be far more expensive. For a drug (or a chip manufacturer or whatever), even a very expensive patent would be negligible relative to the R&D costs. However, it would make a lot of bullshit patents not worth getting.
I think modern drug manufacturing is a lot more nuanced then oh I can copy this chemical. And if it is then that's life of a drug manufacturer, you build that into the price. Like everybody else, I think it's a false political narrative that drugs are magically nuanced in ways other things aren't.
Because we've decided that drugs need to be safe and effective to get approval. And the process for proving that a drug is safe and effective is extremely expensive. If you don't reward companies that do the R&D, there just won't be incentives for private industry to develop drugs. If company A spends $1 billion dollars to develop a new compound and then run clinical trials to prove it's safety, and then company B comes along and manufacturers the same drug but says "it's already been tested on patients by company B, so we shouldn't have to bear any of that cost again, but just the cost of manufacturing the drug itself which is trivial" then you'll have a lot of company Bs but no company As.
That said, maybe patents aren't the right mechanism for this. Maybe just extend the term on existing exclusivity to something similar to the term that patents cover.
> You still get a huge market share/reputation and likely can keep that by being the first to market which is enough reward imo to a product to market.
The data doesn't bear this out. When drugs go generic, the brand drugs' market share overwhelmingly drops in favor of people who buy the generic (insurance companies usually force you to by not paying for the brand). There are exceptions for certain types of drugs.