What are your thoughts on MPE and Midi 2.0 in Ardour?
What are your thoughts on MPE and Midi 2.0 in Ardour?
I have not looked at MIDI 2.0 yet in any level of detail, amazing at that may seem. I don't think MIDI 2.0 really brings much to the table for most users of MIDI, and what it does bring is largely addressed by MPE. However, given some of the deeper changes, it would make sense that whenever we try to tackle the "MPE model", we also pay attention to what MIDI 2.0 requires at the same time.
Having a midi device be able to describe and name its parameters and then be able to ... let me quote soundonsound -
https://www.soundonsound.com/music-business/introducing-midi...
"""MIDI‑CI will allow DAWs to discover a lot more about external gear than they can at the moment, and might even allow editing panels to be built automatically."""
I have a lot of gear that will never speak midi 2.0 but my assumption is some clever person will make a proxy (with a big list of existing gear mappings) that would allow me to select that gear and then expose a midi 2.0 interface to the DAW or a keyboard controller that was midi 2.0
This would really be huge for me and just make life a lot better around the studio.
It has gone nowhere.
There are a number of reasons why, but I would wager that the most important is that people simply do not need this kind of complexity. It is the kind of thing that OEMs can use to build cool devices, rather than the kind of things the overwhelming majority of users ever wants to deal with.
Note that the MIDNAM specification also does a significant part of what you describe above, and although it's not true to say that it has gone nowhere, the industry essentially abandoned it rather than push it forward.
I apologize for sound cynical or skeptical about MIDI 2.0. MIDI 1.0 was a technical and social engineering miracle. But having been around the audio tech industry for 20+ years, I'm not optimistic that the MMA's processes are capable of replicating what was so good about MIDI 1.0 or avoiding the screw-ups they've been involved with since then.
Midi 2.0 seems like its about a sweet spot that will solve real problems.
I'm looking at the midnam files that come with Ardour...
It seems like these are focused on just named patches? I see the spec can do more like parameter names but it doesn't seem like that's been the focus? Is there a bigger pile of work somewhere?
Thanks, I might poke at this a bit and see what I can get working in Ardour.