That doesn't mean there isn't an opportunity cost to providing liquidity through buying up bonds versus other socially productive forms of spending. Just because we have a magic money tree, why does that mean Walmart should be the beneficiary?
That doesn't mean there isn't an opportunity cost to providing liquidity through buying up bonds versus other socially productive forms of spending. Just because we have a magic money tree, why does that mean Walmart should be the beneficiary?
Finally, it's not the Federal Reserve's role to be socially helpful except as to fulfill their dual mandates to 1) minimize inflation and 2) maximize employment.
Pretending there's no limit and no deleterious effect seems wrong. If that were true then the Federal Reserve could just by boobs for all debts and every citizen would be debt free and there would be nothing wrong.
If every time a company struggles the gov step in, because instead of maintaining reserves the companies pay out profit, bonuses and dividends, then large companies will engineer in the need for gov assistance and their ability to self maintain will be lost.
Either way, I wasn't "pretending there's no limit and no deleterious effect". As you stated, that would be wrong. There are obvious and not-so obvious problems with central banks engaging in QE (i.e. buying financial assets as a means of injecting money into the system). But this thread was about QE via corp bonds vs the Fed handing out gifts to the public so I didn't go into that.
They can't, not how bonds work.
> Pretending there's no limit and no deleterious effect seems wrong.
Nobody is pretending. There are many potentially deleterious effects, but amazingly the set of problems people have with this have almost no intersection with the potentially deleterious effects.
> If every time a company struggles the gov step in
This is a pandemic. The government engineered a scenario which destroyed the economy to save lives. Walmart engineered nothing here.
It is astounding how little people understand of what is going on here.
> It is astounding how little people understand of what is going on here.
No, you're just a smug asshole.
Name one.
> Further, we can just change the law, this isn't some immutable truth of central banks.
Well then go change the the law instead of saying that with the law being what it currently is the fed should instead engage in other "socially productive forms of spending".
> Even within the scope of the fed's mandate we could invent ways to invest in infrastructure instead of Walmart.
Invent them then and tell us. The fed can buy bonds, they buy bonds, they can set the interest rate, they set the interest rate. If there is a company building infrastructure that issues bonds then presumably the Fed can buy them, and I'm sure they will because the Fed is trying to flood the system with money, and for the most part indiscriminately with maybe just an eye on credit ratings.