Their’s was demonstrably the best strategy and everyone else is just making excuses.
Their’s was demonstrably the best strategy and everyone else is just making excuses.
Without the same testing capacity, this strategy simply wasn’t available in most other countries. However now that testing capacity has ramped up, we should be able to employ more efficient lockdowns from now on. It’s still not a magic wand though, Germany’s economy has still suffered significantly even with a relatively efficient lockdown.
Also, the choice to offshore medical supply infrastructure was a deliberate one by many wealthy countries. That this was foolish and short-sighted is not any more of an excuse than anything else with their poor responses.
But yes: Vietnam still did great, most likely thanks to very early intervention (as early as January).
Lots of very different countries have beaten the virus in different ways. Apologists for the failed US response have to resort to special pleading: "it's not fair to compare the USA to South Korea ... or Taiwan ... or Germany ... or Australia ... or New Zealand ... or Japan ... or Vietnam ... or China ..." American exceptionalism at its least fine.
For New Zealand they have an extremely widely geographically dispersed population, which you can think of as built-in demographic social distancing. They also locked down early and there was strong popular support for the lockdown.
It's really pretty ridiculous to expect radically different countries with completely different geography, demographics, medical systems and lockdown policies as though they're all assumed to be equivalent as a default. Specific local conditions can have a massive effect. But anyway I'm not even sure I understand what your point is Why do you think these countries outcomes were so radically different from, say, that in New York, or Lombardy? Or what's happening right now in Texas?
I don't know the answer, but is this actually true? Sure, the density as measured as a ratio between population and land mass indicates a dispersed population, but is the population not centered in a handful of cities?
A quick search indicates that Auckland, a single city, contains a third of New Zealand's population.
My point is that many countries with wildly different conditions have successfully suppressed the virus, which I think suggests that just about any country could have suppressed the virus with the right policies. At least, one should not confidently assert that there is no way the USA, western Europe, etc could have successfully suppressed the virus.
The young are less likely to get sick, those who don't get sick are less likely to spread the virus. Youthful demographics are not irrelevant to shutting down viral transmission.
I have had the impression that the age effect on sickness and transmission is much less than on mortality, but I admit I don't remember any specific data on that.
Countries with SARS experience were quick at developing and communicating those strategies. Other countries like NZ and Australia were not absolutely quick but were quick enough because the virus got here later.