They would be great except the problem is once you're done with school, it can be incredibly hard to stay in the US. So we end up losing the people we help train. Fixing it by reducing these students entirely is going in the wrong direction.
Do you have any evidence for this? The incredibly vast amount of research work done by immigrants on these visas probably outweighs any risk they pose as these educated people head back after graduating or try to stay.
You're not crazy. You're a cogent individual deliberately believing something that is not true or guided by reality.
This decision will not be beneficial for national security at all, and that wasn't even used as justification for it.