Breaks some subdomain certs (wildcard doesn't cover *.old.reddit.com), causes links you send to others to not honor their preference, and causes links you follow to default to new Reddit (unless you also run a redirection extension).
I've even found that the apartment building that my friend lives in has an elevator that the button _does_ actually work.
But then you have to keep diverting over to old.reddit.com, when a bunch of links go to either www.reddit.com or np.reddit.com or whatever.