How to Get to Genius
jamesthornton.com
jamesthornton.com
> Thoughts are the neural activity in your brain, and they
> get stored as physical objects -- the neural connections.
> They get stronger as you think more about them and they
> can go away too – so we have a scientific explanation for
> the adage, “Use it or lose it.”
Why do people feel this constant urge to sprinkle their fluff posts with not-even-semi-correct pop-neuroscience? He clearly doesn't know anything about neural plasticity, so why cheapen everything by pretending?For what's commonly called cognitive neuroscience (which generally includes memory, cognition, learning and so on, thereby having the most relevance for a nonspecialist reader), Gazzaniga/Ivry/Mangun (2008) remains an absolutely solid introduction that doesn't dumb stuff down while still providing plenty of illustrations and worthwhile patient cases. Covers basic neurobiology in sufficient detail. My recommendation for this kind of stuff.
For molecular and general neurobiology, I recommend the first few chapters of Squire's "Fundamental Neuroscience." Kandel's good as well. If you're looking for something more basic, Carlson's "Physiology of Behavior" is a brilliant and rather entertaining book.
http://www.ted.com/talks/lang/eng/sebastian_seung.html
The idea that neural connections (synapses) grow stronger from learning is well supported...
"synapses grow stronger when we're awake as we learn and adapt to an ever-changing environment" (http://www.med.wisc.edu/news-events/news/sleep-tempers-growt...)
"Most contemporary neuro-scientists agree that learning takes place at the neural switch points – the synapses. Research has shown that experience can change synapses: they can become either stronger or weaker; and this change can persist for a lifetime. Changes in synaptic conduction are without doubt the basis for learning and long-term memory" (http://www.mentalspaceresearch.com/english-articles/expandin...).
"One area of change is the synapses, the connections between neurons, which are altered as the brain receives stimuli. “What happens when you’re awake is you produce an overall strengthening of synapses,” Dr. Tononi said. “That’s good, because that’s how you learn.”
But that is unsustainable in the long run, because stronger synapses require more energy and material, and there’s a limit to how much of both is available. “It’s as if in the morning you start with a V-6 engine,” he said, “and in the evening you find yourself idling, but you’re running a V-8.” Stronger synapses are also bigger, but the brain cannot grow bigger or denser. “If you strengthen synapses because you learn, soon you’d reach a point where you can’t learn further,” he added.
So Dr. Tononi and a colleague, Chiara Cirelli, have hypothesized that during sleep, the synapses weaken. The downscaling is across the board, so that the synapses’ relative strength is maintained. Those that have been used (those involved in learning) stay stronger than those that haven’t."
(http://www.nytimes.com/2008/01/29/science/29obslee.html?_r=1)
He equates "thoughts" and "neural activity." That's either a vacuous statement (because, assuming materialism, all mental activity is neural activity) or embarrassingly oversimplified. Similar situation for the following two sentences. I'm not disputing synaptic theories of memory/learning; they're common sense these days. Moreover, I'm sure he's derived his presentation from (hopefully sound) science.
But nothing is gained from faux-scientific, superficial neuro-bla. Nothing at all. Reality is much more complicated: usage is but one mechanism by which synaptic strength is modulated. There are several others. Nobody really understands how learning works, or how "thoughts are stored" (whatever that is supposed to mean). Sure, synaptic connections change after learning episodes. But that tells us shit about how to become a genius, or why a (HIGH-LEVEL -- neuroscience has no clue how stuff like this works!) phenomenon like sudden perspective shifts leads to breakthroughs.
So why cheapen solid pop-psychology with insufficient grasp of modern neurobiology?
The importance of perspective shifts isn't a new idea -- Alan Kay stresses the same thing (http://www.ted.com/talks/alan_kay_shares_a_powerful_idea_abo...).
This is what I said:
"BTW I liked your TED talk. My friends and I were discussing it the other day, and I made the analogy of comparing the connectome in your brain to hardware and the thoughts in your mind to software. Is that a fair analogy?
David Rock wrote a book called 'Your Brain at Work' where he says that insights come from detecting weak associations (he gave a Google Tech Talk on this too -- http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XeJSXfXep4M).
If the brain software/hardware analogy is right, is there a similar relationship between weak associations of thoughts and neurons that are "distantly" connected? In other words, are associations weak because they are indirect paths from one node – one neural connection -- to another, and would a more direct path optimize you mental ability?"
This is what Sebastian said:
"The hardware-software analogy is wrong
1) the brain is not a general purpose programmable computer. different areas are specialized to different functions
2) the connectome changes over time, unlike hardware
you're right that direct vs indirect paths do matter, unlike in communication networks. but the weakness of an association might have to do with the strength of synapses, not just the length of the path. i'm addressing these questions in my book which will appear in feb 2012 if all goes well."
So maybe a better analogy for the brain would be a network of specialized computers, like a private cloud connected to the Internet because the cloud can change with demand, and the size of connection and number of hops both affect performance.
For example, pushing data closer to the client is one of the primary reasons CDNs (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Content_delivery_network) were invented -- to optimize content delivery so content is fewer hops away from the client.
And in graph theory a common problem is trying to find the shortest path from one node to another (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shortest_path_problem).
I disagree with the premise that a mere mortal can spontaneously boot strap him-self to a higher plane of thinking through a simple change in perspective. Revolutionary breakthroughs are a product of obsession and hard work. Aha moments are built on top of a lot of grinding. The Principia Mathematica stands testimony to this.
This post could have been written in a much more terse manner. There is a very low information density. We don't need wireframes and tangentially related TED talks to understand this stuff. It feels pedantic at best.
"Developing these rare or unique perspectives usually takes a deliberate and devoted focus on something. Einstein said, 'It's not that I'm so smart, it's just that I stay with problems longer.' Malcolm Gladwell talks about the 10,000-hour rule. He says, 'Studies suggest that the key to success in any field has nothing to do with talent. It's simply practice, 10,000 hours of it — 20 hours a week for 10 years.'"
Think of it this way, if you were omniscient -- meaning you perceive everything, you see everything from every angle -- you would have total perspective. But we're not omniscient -- our perspectives are relatively sparse, but the more associations/connections you make, the the more your perspective grows and you start to see a "bigger picture".
You don't develop understanding by learning raw facts -- understanding comes from relating to other things. It's the connections that matter.
However, the author of the article definitely comes from the camp which mistakes the perspective shift as more important than the hard work. How? Let me count the ways.
1.Sadly, this article succumbs to the myth that Einstein was bad at math. Einstein had fully mastered integral calculus and differential equations by the time he was 15 and achieved full marks for most of his high school subjects. His huge amount of ability allowed him the critical perspective shifts. The author mistakenly thinks dwarves have the vision of giants.
2.The section "Insights from Weak Association" slips into this solipsism with gratuitous flair. I don't believe the "NeuroLeadership Journal" is peer reviewed. However, according to the esteemed, Mark Beeman detecting weak associations may help problem solve. How wonderfully useless. This precedes which states how understanding the problem is "easy" after all.
3. Perspective before focus. This is the title of the third section Sadly, you will not get perspective if you do not focus. Being able to see differently is a product of sweating over it a million different ways. You have it backwards. Tight mental frameworks are the product of focus. Thinking about how you can revolutionize the field before studying it is premature optimization.
I believe that I am exceedingly clear both in my arguments and my opinion of the blog post.
2. The Google TechTalk it references explains "insights from weak associations" in more detail: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XeJSXfXep4M
3. If you don't have perspective, how do you know the thing you're focused on is of any importance? You can see practical examples of this everywhere:
"One of my favourite tuppences for engineers struggling to find a bug is 'breadth first not depth first'. This can be annoying for someone working through complex technical details, because it implies that the solution is actually much simpler if they only looked...I coined this saying because in software matters I find that if we force ourselves to examine the top level considerations first, before tunneling down into the detail of a particular line of inquiry, we can save enormous time" (http://ria101.wordpress.com/2010/02/24/hbase-vs-cassandra-wh...).
Pretty ambiguous imho. And it blatantly plays upon that misconception. "Just" sticking with a problem for a long is not an easy undertaking as the passage makes it out to be.
2."David Rock is a thought leader for the brain-based approach to coaching. David coined the term 'NeuroLeadership' and co-founded the NeuroLeadership Institute, Journal and Summit. He is also the founder and CEO of Results Coaching Systems,"
His resume speaks volumes.
3.I was working a matrix multiplication algorithm this weekend. I improved by 13x over the naive case. It ended up being one of the faster ones among my peers. How? I ground it the fuck out. I read 4 papers. I coded for hours on end and when I wasn't coding I was thinking hard about it. You cannot see the vista if you deign not to climb the mountain.
Insight: - the power of acute observation and deduction, penetration, discernment, perception called intellection or noesis.
-an understanding of cause and effect based on identification of relationships and behaviors within a model, context, or scenario
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Insight)
How would you have been able to come up with a new algorithm without understanding why it works? Perspective is understanding "why".