The illusion of control, and how to give it up
nautil.us
nautil.us
"The option they bought from me"
The option was sold and backed by the bank at which the author worked, and he didn't personally lose $200 million. Seems like he's still very much deep in the illusion of control.
Unless he personally lost $200 million, or he somehow needs to pay it back to the bank, then no, he is not ultimately responsible for the deal at all.
What you are saying is that it might have felt that way to him because of his involvement and that it's understandable to feel that way. And that's ok. But it is also very tone deaf to use that language in an article about supposedly dispelling the illusion of control.
In any case, here's the definition of liability: "the state of being responsible for something, especially by law". So liability is responsibility.
This is one such use. Your hair-splitting complaints are not particularly appropriate to this forum as they do not effectively serve to make its communication more effective; nor do I have any reason to believe they are they an effective psychological marker of responsibility and the illusion of control as you assert.
They are different words for a reason.
If anything, you are essentially making my point. The guy in the story was not liable for the $200 million (beyond his job), hence he didn't personally lose the money, even though he says "I lost $200 million".
What does "control" mean in this context anyway when you have no skin in the game?
The illusion of control and how to recognise you never had it
Maybe it was also my misreading: what he gave up was the illusion.
(Btw I did read the article, the above reads like I commented on the HN headline)
EDIT - I'm throttled (I imagine due to comments like the following), so cannot reply below:
> Nobody needs a phd to understand that circumstances and chance have a much bigger influence...
Some depth in psychology and neurology can also help one realize that you do not actually know the thoughts and abilities of other people - rather, this is how the mind evolved to perceive and model the external world (persons, etc), and how the subconscious communicates predictions based on that model to the conscious mind.
So, I maintain my assertion that an understanding of how the mind (that which most substantially differentiates us from all other living things) works has great utility.
"Am I the master of my destiny?" is the real question behind the illusion of control.
Am I succeeding because of my skill, talent and actions or just lucky? What part is due to luck and which is due to my skill?
He points out that the illusion of control is necessary because reality could cause depression, making people too paralyzed to act and therefore making bad situations worse.
We are all going into the unknown all the time, predicting the future is not a solvable problem, but you can train yourself to aim better from past attempts.
I don't know if you get to choose between chess and cards. In Starcraft (and chess to a lesser degree) you still have risks in the unknown that can be mapped as a probability function. For a given build order you may know that the best unit is X, but there's still a chance your opponent produces a unit that is counter-valent to the optimal.
In finance or cards you still have information about concrete events like ipo launch dates and cards have chips that are always shown and a number of cards remaining, that do not require probabilities to know or exploit.
Which one takes more prominence depends on the task at hand. And if one is prominent, the other strategy is nestled inside and shrouds from above.
You can't stop the sun from rising but you can stop the raccoons from using your trash cans as a salad bar.
But let's face it Wall St. makes money betting with low latency (or advanced notice) market data and news, insider info, and through complex chicanery to hide strats about said betting. It's moving value around into different peoples' pockets while maintaining a pretense of functioning as a funding and value conversion platform.
I don't get it, how would this be profitable for the bank?