Also why would you need to take any risks if you think you know everything already?
I don't think you know many arrogant people, I deal with people at my company that are both stubborn and usually wrong, which is a lethal combo. You have to workaround these people or else the project won't get done.
I share your final observation though.
> Why would you expose your opinions to challenge if you know they are right?
You expose them to challenge because you know they're right; you don't act to protect them by keeping them hidden and not testing them. You "put them under load." This is basically mental and rhetorical dogfooding.
edit: I think the difference is between "I think I'm right" and "I want to believe I'm right." If you want to protect your sense that you're right, you'll be both hesitant to test your beliefs and vicious in their defense. Conversely, if you're attached to the actual state of being right, you'll trial your beliefs and abandon them if they fail you. Arrogance, or at least a moderate degree of it, can help you act like the latter by making ideas seem more reliable than they deserve, creating natural trials.
edit: I guess the common thread is that arrogance promotes exploration by suppressing fear of loss.
Sure, there have been occasions when that has been the wrong approach. But it's also been the right approach in a profitable enough way to compensate for the failures!