1. the complainant told google to delete something
2. google says no
3. the complainant complains to the DPA, who agrees with them and fines google 600k
The implementation of "right to be forgotten" is problematic. It forces service providers to take down content on the request of a complainant, without going through judicial approval. It's up to the service provider to render a decision, and if they wrongly refuse the request, they could be subject to a fine. This is problematic because there's almost zero incentive for the service provider to keep the content up, and plenty of potential downside if they keep the content up. Thus, the "safe" decision is to always comply with any request, regardless of merit. This is the same problem with DMCA, where every request gets rubberstamped, because if you don't comply with the request and it later turns out to be valid, you lose your safe harbor status and can be held liable for the infringement. Needless to say, this effect is terrible for free speech on the internet. Also, unlike court, there isn't any "defense" so to speak. Who is supposed to be representing the public interest or the author?