The most important kind of intelligence is knowing what one does not know. There's a mindset counter to this, that substitutes a model for reality and then fervently believes the model. Math and physics exerts a very strong selection force attracting people fond of this substitution. The responses here do not surprise me.
Our extrapolations always take the form of moving along a tangent vector out from prior experience. Prior to relativity, Newtonian physics was the belief that we actually lived in that tangent space. Surprises come when the deviations are large enough for reality to curve away from our models. I thought I understood how materials behaved, till I was stuck briefly on a mountain at -30F. People dance on decks that collapse. They smoke joints on exposed foam mattresses. Surprises happen.
I appreciate that in this universe, our experience confirmed that physicists' absolute faith in the Trinity experiment was well-founded. A billion runs of parallel universes would have likely work out. Take this out to a quadrillion runs? It turns out that alien life has always been here at the subatomic level. Like dogs not liking fireworks, that nuclear ping really pissed them off, so they engineer a virus that wipes us out. Or it turns out that indeed there's a quantum basis to consciousness. After that nuclear ping, the atmosphere is fine, but everyone on that side of the Earth keels over, no longer able to think.
The Trinity test was a step further out along the tangent vector than we'd ever taken before. We were deliberately creating a version of a Carrington Event on Earth, with absolute certainty that we understood and anticipated all consequences. The odds of calamity were small, but our existence was at stake.