Also, either way, what kinds of plants can you grow without irrigation or rain for a full summer? I'm guessing only ones whose roots go deep enough into the pile?
If you plant one by one, neatly spaced apart, you won't have this type of nutrient cycling and moisture uptake.
My parents have just added a few to their setup, but we're in winter here in Australia so yet to see their effectiveness through summer.
Potatoes on a 2nd year old hugelkultur are amazing!
I live in zone 6b Connecticut