This is where I was leading with my original question. If the IMs are contested, what happens then? Do we go to the ISP? What if the session is encrypted? Do we go to the IM service provider? Ultimately, the burden of proof should be on CX to actually prove those are the IMs, right? Would CX have the ability to request logs from a provider anyway, since this is a civil case?
I think it's important to know the answers to these questions because anyone can show up in court one day claiming to have incriminating IM chats for XYZ - so the question is how to prove it's false, or what happens if they are false.