Too much of the US economy these days has become about wealth extraction or speculation, rather than real wealth creation. We’ve outsourced large portions of our manufacturing ecosystem while arguing that design, services and finance will make up for it.
This book traces the root of the problem back to changes in how Economics analyzes and measures economic activity, and examines some industries through this lense, including VC.
Notably, prior to the development of Marginal Utility, economists from Adam Smith to Karl Marx and everyone in between were concerned with the distinction between productive and unproductive economic activity.
For example, manufacturing was productive and wealth-creative, while rents levied by the landed gentry were unproductive and extractive. Any form of cornering a market and extracting rent is assumed extractive, unless proven otherwise.
The term they used was the Production Boundary, with productive activities on one side and unproductive on the other. A few, like law, that were inherently unproductive but that were necessary inputs to productive activity, are situated on the border.
Marginal Utility made value subjective rather than objective. If a product or activity has demand for any reason and could thus fetch a price on a market, then it has value and is productive. This made economics more mathematically tractable as well, and became the dominant Economic theory. But it has also enabled extractive and speculative activities to claim to be productive, and thus gain political acceptance and support.
The book argues this is the root of the problem facing the US and other developed countries, and that solving it requires new economic measurements and theories that restore the distinction between productive activity vs extractive or speculative activity.