Cellphone Radiation May Alter Your Brain. Let’s Talk.
nytimes.com
nytimes.com
"In healthy participants and compared with no exposure, 50-minute cell phone exposure was associated with increased brain glucose metabolism in the region closest to the antenna. This finding is of unknown clinical significance."
The specific finding referred to is localized mean differences in brain glucose metabolism of 2.4 μmol/100 g per minute (a 7% increase).
The linked article is a fluff piece providing "advice" for people wanting to avoid exposure to cell phone radiation. The study makes no claims regarding possible health hazards related to their findings.
To do so at this point would be reckless. There's a concern here and certain steps ("advice") seem reasonable.
It could be years, if not a decade or more, before any hazards are clearly known. Better to be safe. We're born with only one brain and neural implants are still a ways off.
I'm not going to claim that it's impossible, just highly unlikely that this causes significant harm.
It could be nothing. The phones could merely excite the brain regions with no long-term deleterious effects. But what's the harm if they're wrong? More people using wired headsets?
If a headset isn’t feasible, holding your phone just slightly away from your ear can make a big difference; the intensity of radiation diminishes sharply with distance.
But today’s ubiquitous smartphones emit even more radiation as they transmit more, and more complex, data.
Many cellphones emit the most radiation when they initially establish contact with the cell tower, making their “digital handshake.” To reduce exposure it’s best to wait until after your call has been connected to put your cellphone next to your ear.
During the ensuing conversation, it’s advisable to tilt the phone away from your ear when you are talking and only bring it in close to your ear when you are listening.
Moreover, your cellphone emits less when you are stationary because when you are moving rapidly — say, in a car or train — it must repeatedly issue little bursts of radiation to make digital handshakes with different towers as it moves in and out of range.
Any situation where your cellphone has a weak signal indicates it has to work harder and thus will emit more radiation.
I'll leave it to the Google-fu of the HN community to weigh these claims. But the reporter has cited expertise where necessary. That's far beyond what I find on blogs or forums, including this one. In a evolving field of science, isn't that the best we can hope for?
That certainly made me question why the article was trying to project some paranoia around this.
A tangential note: I congratulate NYT for actually linking to the original JAMA report! Hope other journalists follow suit. Does anyone know if NYT has always done this, btw?
According to the abstract, they tested phones on and muted or off. A phone that is powered on (but not on a call) shouldn't be expected to use the radio much. Is it the case that the only difference was the power being on or off?
Any explanation given for why they compared powered-on vs. powered-off instead of, e.g., airplane vs. non-airplane mode?
Next, every phone I've seen with a mute feature mutes the audio FROM your phone, not TO your phone. Some phones also make a hiss even when they're supposed to be silent. Electronics can themselves hum, sometimes at a high enough frequency that only some people can hear it. Is it possible that there was an auditory difference between the two test conditions?
Cell phones that are off vs. on look different (e.g., screen) and feel different (e.g., heat generation). How was blinding maintained?
Speaking of that, how did they control for one being warmer than the other? Abstract says it was placed on the ear, so assumably the subject could feel that.
When they say that phones were placed on the left and right ears, what do they mean? Hopefully they used a random ear for the "on" phone.