Hans Holbein plays a part as Henry's favourite painter and this is how I learnt about him.
Hans Holbein plays a part as Henry's favourite painter and this is how I learnt about him.
The historian keeps mentioning in a very jovial way that at the beginning of the Tudor era The Church was the second biggest land owner in England. That doesn't sound jovial to me. Further, the burgeoning middle class was developing in part as sharecroppers on church land, half of England's exports were sheep wool, the Church is responsible for a large fraction of the social safety net, owned many of the mills (and enforced a monopoly with the sharecroppers) and was selling booze at festivals.
It paints for me a much more complex picture of Henry VIII's motivations for breaking with the Church. There's this sort of notion that it was a frivolous thing for him to do and now I'm examining that assertion a bit more skeptically, as spin. There were so many subtle and not-so-subtle ways in which it objectively represented a threat to sovereignty, one that was growing larger by the decade.
I'd nearly convinced myself to watch The Tudors and now I think I probably will.
The real goal was to have _legitimate_ male heirs. It was never much of a problem for kings to have affairs, even out of wedlock children. For example, Henry FitzRoy - a son from an affair.
However, as you mention, the church had a lot of wealth including land. Conveniently, once Henry was 'pope' of his own religion he could go about stripping the monasteries of their wealth.
Actually I don't know what was done with that money. Presumably it was part of the motivation, but who knows.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dissolution_of_the_Monasteries
For example, discussion of 'spiritual income streams' and advowsons, and other obscure topics. I wonder how many people have knowledge in medieval ecclesiastical accounting...
We complain of "cancel culture" now, but in Tudor England, being "cancelled" meant having all your possessions confiscated, being confined to the Tower of London, undergoing torture to get a confession, and then having your head chopped off in public.