I also believe in his genuine reasons and motivations for resigning, and the integrity it showed. (Obligatory: yes, he's in his 60s who's made millions, at some point you gotta retire, and it's easy to show integrity when you clearly don't need to work again)
Having said that, I'm kind of surprised he's surprised by the overall reaction that he got when he quit, and in interviews since then.
It's popular, easy, and desirable to dunk on Amazon. It's the best form of mainstream journalistic clickbait because it brings in and unites the left (who want improved worker rights, and Jeff B is a poster child for wealth imbalance) and the right (who are mad at Jeff's perceived left-leaning politics and criticism of Donald Trump via the Washington Post).
It is NOT popular to question the very fabric of our western capitalism. Overtures about unsustainable wealth inequality do not resonate well in the mainstream. At the fringes, the right blames the rest of the world, and looks to isolate; the left is readying the guillotines.
I think Tim should have known that his message would be misconstrued by both other Amazonians who remained and wrote defensive blog posts, and the rest of the world who's holding him up as some Anti-Amazon Crusader.
I believe his mistake was to immediately start talking about worker's rights when his actual ethical qualm was about the chilling effect of silencing whistleblowers. But...then he wouldn't have had the NYTimes writing follow ups months later.