I tried the craigslist/odesk/etc. route with pretty mixed results.
About a year ago I found a new strategy: I find sites that I like and email the owner to ask who designed it. Half the time it's someone in house but the rest of the time they're usually happy to pass along the designer's contact info.
It's more time consuming this way because you have to do the outreach yourself, but the quality I've gotten has been spectacular.