Any specific examples?
According to https://developer.gnome.org/gtk3/stable/gtk-migrating-3-x-to..., the changes were pretty minor.
According to https://developer.gnome.org/gtk3/stable/gtk-migrating-3-x-to..., the changes were pretty minor.
This was apparently a part of a deliberate strategy around GNOME branding. The GNOME developers wanted all GTK apps to have one consistent look-and-feel, they wanted people to associate this look with GNOME, and they wanted people to start thinking of GTK apps as "GNOME Apps."
More recently, they crippled existing functionality for server side-window decorations in Wayland (which literally every other toolkit supports), because GNOME decided to use exclusively client-side decorations. They vetoed all of the reasonable seeming workaround proposals, essentially telling developers to either use GNOME's decorations or to manually draw the close/maximize/minimize buttons.
Honestly, all of the crap that systemd gets should be redirected towards GTK/GNOME. I've never seen a group of developers act in such bad faith.
Themers were warned, that the styling engine was under heavy rework. Gtk people could either wait few years until it's done and be stuck with Gtk2 meanwhile, or go out with Gtk3, which has relatively stable public API and internal API under rework. It's no brainer to take the same way they took. They also communicated this, so anyone who ignored their advice has no basis to complain. They were told exactly what is going to happen, and that they will either have to keep up, or not do it yet.
Switch to client-side decorations was also done for a very good reason. There's a post by Rasterman (author of the Enlightenment WM) on reddit, where he details it why - and he is not even associated with Gnome. Windows and Mac also do client-side decorations, you just cannot see it, because clients cannot connect directly to the compositors, they have to use the client side libraries that handle that. Which is exactly what Gtk does.
> API changes every minor release.
vetinari:
> the changes were pretty minor.
Was this pun intended? ;-)