...this isn’t normal? All the fiction I read has always been present tense.
I can think of a handful of exceptions where the whole story itself is narrated from the perspective of someone telling a story, but those are notable exceptions for having a weird narrative gimmick (e.g. the excellent but dated Icehenge is written in the past tense because it consists of personal diary entries).
Good storytelling just pulls you in. Our brain fills in the rest.