Hacker News Reader

HNHacker News

Top New Best Ask Show Jobs

Comment by enneff | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

enneff·

You’re just saying the same things older people have been saying about new music since time immemorial.

View on HN

Generalizing criticisms as the same as past criticisms is a sidestep rather than a point.

Perhaps, yet: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/02/07/opinion/what-these-grammy...

How about from other established rappers?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g0OdmRtuQew

Admittedly they are now "older" :)

You say they're older as a joke, but it's very much relevant. Old artists dismissing the developments and approaches of their younger colleagues is a tale as old as time.

And yet - dismissing criticisms of older people by younger people as "you're just old" rather than answering the criticism is just as old.

Older gens hated rap when I was a kid and I was thirsty to defend it with supported reasons

Kids today just say OK boomer and move on. Bc they have no defense .

Established older musicians hated The Beatles.

Generalizing criticisms as the same as past criticisms is a sidestep rather than a point.

That's true and yet the decreasing revenue, monetization, and relentless cost-cutting is real as well.

Concerns about making money are not going to destroy art. Almost all art through history has been made by people trying to make a living, not trying to express for its own sake.

We don't have a thousand years of portraiture of the elite because artists were just absolutely convinced that was the ultimate expression of the medium.

You should say mainstream art in any era.

The lack of discoverability and gatekeeping (to some extent) ensures that unpromoted art will not be known. When did the last non-supported musician hit it big? Artist support and development is important as well.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com