The question is how high the share of passive investment can go before we see misallocation.
The question is how high the share of passive investment can go before we see misallocation.
I recommend you read up on the following (from me elsewhere on this topic):
> So what would happen if the majority of investors started to buy the market and stopped trying to beat the market?
> Mispricings would start to develop regularly, and the people that had continued to try and pick stocks would be able to profit. The profits that these people made would attract other people, and eventually everyone would return to chasing the dream of beating the market. Behavioral finance plays a huge role in market efficiency; nobody wants to accept being average by taking what the market gives them when there are hot shot managers that promise to consistently beat their benchmark. There is a lot more emotional attraction to investing with the guy, or to being the guy that can beat the market.
The concern that passive/index investing will ruin The Market is just not something we need to worry about.
Jack Bogle made the claim that even if 90% of the market went passive, the remaining 10% would probably be enough to keep things going:
* https://www.forbes.com/sites/greatspeculations/2019/02/12/a-...
* https://www.ft.com/content/4594f554-ba1a-11e7-9bfb-4a9c83ffa...
I'm less worried about the issue of market and price efficiencies, and more about shareholder votes and company management decisions. How do passive, potentially 'non-opinionated' index funds vote on various measures?
Someone could make their own "index fund" with 10% of it allocated to FAANG, maybe 20% of it in the largest tech names overall, and then a distribution of the largest market cap names, and lo and behold, one has an s&p 500 "index fund". Tesla's about to be added to the S&P 500. There are strong opinions on both sides - it's going up, no, it's going down. You don't have much of a choice if you're a Boglehead who bought into the S&P 500, you're just in it for the ride.
There are index funds of every publicly traded company in the US:
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russell_3000_Index
Vanguard themselves have changed things so that employees no longer have the option of choosing the S&P 500 fund in their own retirement accounts, but rather the Total Market fund:
* https://www.marketwatch.com/story/vanguard-thinks-its-own-em...
* https://www.marketwatch.com/story/bogle-explains-why-vanguar...
> You don't have much of a choice if you're a Boglehead who bought into the S&P 500, you're just in it for the ride.
Anyone investing in equities is just in it for the ride, as it is impossible to predict what will happen:
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Random_Walk_Down_Wall_Street
An individual's best bet, long term: buy as much of 'The Market' as you can. The greater, the better. The S&P 500 is simply a smaller portion of the market, and while not bad, may not be ideal:
* https://www.pwlcapital.com/should-you-invest-in-the-sp-500-i...
So people like Jim Simons are merely the luckiest people alive?
The average person earns the average market return, less fees; that's a tautology. Unless you have some reason to believe you aren't average, most people are better off following your advice. It's what I do, personally.
But the idea that no one is winning at this game flies in the face of a lot of evidence.
No one reasonable, not even Fama and French who came up with the Efficient Market Hypothesis, claim that the market is 100% efficient.
And given that no one knows anything about Jim Simon's Medallion Fund, we actually have no idea how successful they are. But given the quantities and/or trading volumes possibly involved, they don't have to be right very often.
In a perfectly efficient market, it's 50/50 whether you'll get the better end of the deal. Now think of a casino: for many games the house's edge is only 1.5% (e.g. blackjack, baccarat, three-card poker).
* https://www.gambling.com/ca/online-casinos/strategy/10-casin...
* https://wizardofodds.com/gambling/house-edge/
But that's still enough for a casino to make make money.
It may be the Simons et co have just an edge of a few percent points, but they make up their profit on volume.
> But the idea that no one is winning at this game flies in the face of a lot of evidence.
There are plenty of people that are winning. It's just the people that win one year rarely win a few years in a row (never mind 10+):
* https://www.tma-invest.com/spiva-data-reveals-15-years-of-ac...
But of course, a properly diversified index fund portfolio contains much more than just the S&P500. Mine has some thousand global stocks, on the order of 5000.
SPY is hardly diversified. A far better and pretty easy portfolio consists of a global financial assets allocation: US stocks and bonds, developed world ex-US stocks and bonds, emerging markets stocks and bonds, real estate and commodities. 10-12 ETFs will do it.