How Germany re-introduced border controls (FIA)

blog.zoller.lu

2 points·thierryzoller··4 comments

Thanks for sharing the information. I find it saddening that there is no broad discussion on the measures taken and their effectiveness. This would be rather important as many different groups of people suffered disproportionally during the lockdown. (Everywhere)

While I’m sure that this void of dicsussions will be filled by researchers, I’m not sure that the derived knowledge will arrive at the decision makers.

How is there no broad discussion? There's dozens of papers on the topic, both scientific and of the pseudoscientific "lockdown is worse than COVID, which is just a flu. here's a linear regression model"/"let's look at data that wasn't available to policy makers at the time" variety, and German media doesn't go a week without discussing the political or societal impact of one measure or another for a few months now.

I would not rate the current news reporting as broad discussion. The discourse in the media is biased and not helpful with regard to the future.

It’s 80% parents complaining, bashing of food production plants, cooks going crazy and driving to the right edge of the spectrum. Reports of teens and young adults bashing glass on the week ends. All these reports burry the helpful discussions.

With regard to the scientific progress I have nothing to say as I’m not up to date. However producing high quality research takes some round trips to settle to an stable state. Nothing wrong with that process but the gained knowledge must be distributed back to the people. Currently this does not happen. Or: it happens and nobody is listening.

FIA Access to documents showing on what basis Germany reintroduced bordercontrol during the period of March 2020.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com