Protected vs Private Scope: Arrogance, Fear, and Handcuffs
vancelucas.com
vancelucas.com
Maybe I'm missing something, but I kind of agree with the (italicized) straw man argument the article is trying to refute. My private implementation details should be irrelevant if I give you a public API, and it's likely that I have thought it through enough to tell what'll be useful. Furthermore I can change the implementation without breaking you. If you need to muck around with the private implementation details, there's something missing from the public API. What happens if the original author wants to change the implementation later?
Hiding the implementation details just seems like reasonable encapsulation to me. Is there something specific to the PHP world which places less emphasis on this than I'm accustomed to?