As common as this argument is, I've always found for me that there's a hierarchy in "ease of use" for text selection that isn't quite as simple as "device X is always better". From quickest to slowest:
* Keyboard command that requires no counting or precision and has no easily-confused variants. In almost all editors this encompasses up, down, left, right, home, end, select or delete a line, and so on; some editors have more sophisticated ones like "select all in enclosing characters", or Vim's non-parameterized text objects ("cw" for "change word" as opposed to "dt6f" for "delete to the sixth occurrence of 'f' or maybe to the character in front of it, I always forget which").
* Mouse selection in any editor that lets you do multiple clicks to change selection object (e.g.: single click character, double click word, triple click line; on a Mac this is nearly any editor, including the text box I'm typing in right now). This isn't as precise as a correctly-executed keyboard command like "dt6f" or some Emacs equivalent, but it requires less cognitive switching: you don't have to think about the command and you don't have to do any counting. You just know you want to select from there to there. If you mess up, it rarely requires any effort to recover.
* Keyboard commands that require you to think carefully before composing them. This is where Vim, god love it, sometimes falls down hard. I know exactly what I want to select, but I have to stop and think about the "best" way to select it, and if I screw it up, I have to get back to where I was and try again -- which may require yet more thinking. I don't doubt that there are people who are just super good at this and get it right first try evey time, and those people are... well, probably not much faster than someone who gets selection right with the mouse every time.
tl;dr: Mice do not suck, and I like trackpads, dammit.