Programmers like using vim because it feels like solving a puzzle or RTS micro'ing and/or they have already sunk a huge amount of time into it and aren't willing to walk away (which is fine, but it's not evidence that these tools are better.)
Starting fresh (i.e. no experience with an IDE or vi/emacs) there is zero productivity benefit to choosing vi or emacs over a real IDE in this day and age.
Disclaimer: I am a former vi (~5 years) and emacs (~20 years) fanatic.