Another interesting variant might be: payment unlocks the destination link for X minutes. (After that, the true destination URL is changed somehow. Yes, that adds complication on the true hosting site or the necessity for Gumroad to proxy.)
So in a sense you don't care if people share the link for that period... maybe you even want them to, like a time-limited offer, so that they post to all their friends, "get it while it's hot!"
(The price could also rise or fall after each purchased open-period... perhaps even, depending on the number of downloads during the last open period.)