Hacker News Reader

Comment by Dylan16807 | Hacker News Reader

Were you stuck with 2.4GHz for a reason? I can't imagine how bad that would be in an apartment.

Depends on the apartment. In some, it's not as congested as it used to be because so many people have moved to 5GHz.

It's still amazing to me, though, that so much new gear is still 2.4GHz only. I bought a brand-new, top-of-the-line air filter earlier this year, and even at close to $500, 2.4GHz is the only option.

....why would an air filter have WiFi in the first place?

You could ask the same thing about light bulbs, but they do.

You often want to control brightness and possibly color on light bulbs, and it's good if that can be integrated with other systems so you can have central control and automation. Wifi may not be the best way to connect, but it's reasonable.

With an air filter, do you ever want to control it? Naively I'd think that you'd want to leave it on unless you're going to be gone for a week or more. And even in that case it's probably easier to flip the switch.

Would it tell you when it needs a filter change? Would that actually work better than a calendar?

While I somewhat agree with you, it's possible to do some pretty advanced/nifty things with advanced automation platforms like Home assistant. There are prebuilt extensions for things like air quality index, so in theory, you could set up a rule to run your air filters when the exterior air quality is above a certain threshold of dirty. The same could be done for indoor air quality if you had a local sensor monitoring it (can be done pretty cheaply with a Pi but I've seen off the shelf products as well)

Reply on news.ycombinator.com