You could use the existing healthcare exchange, and just give people a certain percent of their salary that can only be used to buy healthcare. Then let them buy as they choose.
The problem with switching healthcare in America is that any new system that doesn't allow Americans to think, "I've got mine, you can worry about you" is difficult. Whether that's forced exchanges where everyone pays the same or universal healthcare (where everyone pays the same).
The truly crazy part is that core issues with the system weren’t addressed over the last 70 or so years. Not working should not mean that I’m only able to participate in health-seeking behaviour if I’m wealthy enough to maintain my own health care coverage.
Not to mention conflicts of interest, had a former classmate who’s an ER doctor tweet that he saw a patient who’s chronic condition was causing emergency healthcare needs because insurance was paying for treatment every 4 weeks when the doctor prescribed every 3.
With employee unions being neutered in the past century, and exponential privatized healthcare cost increases, you start to see broad swaths of employees go without insurance in the US, while other countries nationalized their healthcare to keep costs down and continue providing it to their people.
Even if you drove 2 hours a week, there's still 1 reason to prefer being an employee over a contractor: Minimum wage. Uber drivers might only make peanuts once you factor in gas, car payments, and all the time they wait between rides. At least an employee driving 2 hours a week will get a fair paycheck.
Right now they do that for contractors. After the drivers are reclassified as employees, things might change.
Setting and maintaining a new schedule would ADD to operating costs (gotta pay someone to administer the calendar), so there has to be some other reason.
Is there some magical cost per-driver that nobody (even the Uber CEO) seems to be able to articulate? Stuff like withholding for W2s seems to scale really well. The only cost I can think of that doesn't scale basically linearly with hours worked is healthcare (only kicks in at 30hrs/week).
If anything, Uber and Lyft should be threatening to limit drivers to 30hrs/week. That's what I'd bet on actually happening.
Because in no universe does it ever make sense to pay healthcare and numerous other benefits to an "employee" who is working 2 hours a week. Thats why.
> Is there some magical cost per-driver
Yes. It is called fixed costs. Full time employees have a certain level of fixed costs. The obvious example being healthcare.
In other words, the same reason why restaurants don't allow a waiter to show up to work for 2 hours at 4AM.