https://searchengineland.com/google-to-add-attribution-to-li...
The dismissal seems logical to me
https://searchengineland.com/google-to-add-attribution-to-li...
The dismissal seems logical to me
That said, it would've been just if Google would pay for access to Genius' particular, well-curated, "source" database of lyrics, especially given that they're basically stealing traffic.
Here's an interesting question: if Genius closed up shop tomorrow, how long would it take Google to become the primary source of song lyrics online (by rebuilding Genius's dataset from general Internet harvesting)?
Even if Google scraped it on purpose in order to steal traffic, it would likely be legal.
But physical analogies to IP fall apart quickly so I'm not going to encourage people to read into that too deeply
If you find something verbatim identical in a bunch of different places, you've got a strong case that it's just information, because if it were original creative output it wouldn't show up identically in multiple places.
If it turns out everyone was plagiarizing a single source, but you were unaware and took down the offending content when asked, you won't have much in the way of legal liability.