Sure, but could you convince someone to pay you $100k for it?
I see very little effort to create a memorable logo. All these logos look very much alike and neither of them feel like they have any soul to convey.
There is a hint at minimalist design, however I’d argue that minimal is easy to learn, hard to master.
What do you feel when you look at it? I feel nothing. They are just printing out their name in different variations.
Don’t get me wrong, I am not somebody who thinks good design is easy. Never said that. I do however believe that a brand needs some kind of character and uniqueness to their brand and these illustrations feel extremely generic.
Keep in mind that this logo was done for a very physical medium. And you're viewing it through an entirely digital medium - something neither Jobs nor Rand could have envisioned back then.
I would like to think that if Rand was designing a logo for the digital age, his approach would be entirely different
There is a whole book about this: The Interface: IBM and the Transformation of Corporate Design, 1945 -- 1976 by John Harwood. It's online:
https://muse.jhu.edu/book/24792
On the importance of IBM's design, Paul Rand wrote, "IBM's products are too complex to be understood by the average buyer. [They] must rely on IBM's reputable name." (quoted in Ch 1, p. 27 in Harwood).
Not so much for the rest which I am seeing presented here though.
Now, that's quite a statement. Those Fiverr designers must have left a lot of money on the table. Could you please show these better logos?
I’ve seen first hand bosses of companies favor designs (half way decent stuff) that appealed to their tastes, but there were elements of the company that knew his/her taste was a little bland.