https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_household...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_household...
More simply, if you save then spend, wealth-based measures will rate you as better off than a person with higher income who just spends. That doesn't make sense.
edit: if you want to cook up some evidence, look at a scatter plot of some indicator of age (national average age?) vs national average wealth. I suspect, given the countries at the top of the list, you'll end up with a pretty good r.
Not entirely. Having a safety net might be the difference between having a home/food and being on the street but having savings and a safety net allows you to live your previous comfortable life while not working. If you have a healthy savings then you can afford to willingly leave your current job and have some time to yourself while you look for a better job.
Your own money can be used for whatever you want and no need to beg and justify before a government employee.
Keeping money reserved for hardships is a lot like having spent the money, since you can no longer use that money to increase your standard of living. If you put away $50,000 in case of job loss or health problems, you've bought resilience at the opportunity cost of $50,000 worth of something else. If you change your mind later and spend it, you just traded in your resilience for other goods and services. You have the benefit of resilience or the benefit of whatever else you might buy with that money, but not both at the same time.
When you look at consumption numbers for a country, they already include what people have spent to deal with hardships. Wealth, however, doesn't tell you how much in poverty someone had to live in order to save that wealth.
Insurance is a formal way of spending money on resilience. Insurance, though, has the advantage of pooling risk among a large number of people. You don't actually have to save up millions to be insured for millions in healthcare bills. Someone with excellent insurance but little savings can have both more resilience and a higher standard of living than someone who lives in poverty to save every penny, but doesn't spend on insurance.
Behavioural economics has long focused on more sensible sets of metrics.
Wealth doesn't capture that. For example, you might have someone living in extreme poverty in Guatemala who has no electricity or running water, a small home with a mud floor, and eats mostly rice and beans and similar. If this person has no debt, they might have a very small but positive net worth. Meanwhile, you can have someone from America with negative net wealth living a middle class life. The Guatemalan might be spending the equivalent of $600 per year, while the American might be spending 50x that. Looking at spending better captures who is living in poverty.
Wealth can also fail to capture how the wealthy live. Warren Buffett is notoriously frugal. Looking at wealth, you'd find he's about 180,000x wealthier than the mean American adult. Yet he has one house which he bought for $31,500 in 1958, and apparently eats breakfast at McDonald's each morning for no more than $3.17. The vast majority of his wealth will be going to charity. Looking at his spending gives you a more accurate picture of how he lives than looking at his wealth.
So that's $4500 a year more the average US citizen has in total expenditure that isn't some type of luxury good or indicator of a better life. It's just survival.
I mean Australia beats the USA by any quality of life index out there. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Where-to-be-born_Index
> I mean Australia beats the USA by any quality of life index out there.
I don't think it's worth it to get into an argument about which country is "better", except to say a lot of indexes are designed to advocate for the creator's goals rather than as a useful comparison. E.g. your linked ranking uses "the share of women holding seats in national Houses of Assembly". Is that really a useful comparison point for quality of life?
Yes but the point is that's one example. I'm not going to got through the full list but i can't think of one USA government provided service that's better quality or requires less private intervention compared to social democracies like Australia and it shows up in so many intangible ways. eg. little things like the Australian government provided online tax filing. In the USA people need to pay to file taxes online (sure paper is free but ugh what a hassle). More private toll roads in the USA. Public housing is more common per capita in Australia. Australias national broadband network (i still can't get fibre here in the USA but i had it in regional Australia), etc. Again i'm not going to keep going except to say that i've lived in both nations and it's really obvious.
In more socialist countries per capita spending can be seen as lower but the services are better despite no spending from consumers going to them. The spending comes from the government. You can't compare spending between the USA and Australia for this reason.
> More private toll roads in the USA.
And more public. More roads period. The interstate highway system is one of the modern wonders of the world.
> Public housing is more common per capita in Australia.
I’m not sure if this is true, but I’d argue it’s not a good thing.
> Australias national broadband network (i still can't get fibre here in the USA but i had it in regional Australia), etc. Again i'm not going to keep going except to say that i've lived in both nations and it's really obvious.
This is an extremely strange one. Internet in Australia is so bad it’s painful. The national network is a joke.