Something doesn't add up.
Something doesn't add up.
"usefulness of firefox" + "usefulness of extensions" > "usefulness of chrome"
after removal
"usefulness of firefox" < "usefulness of chrome"
And that's not counting disappointment/animosity towards firefox for breaking the implicit contract.
I am not arguing that this was the main issue that have caused firefox usage to drop, as according to stats on AMO, extensions never had very large usage. But i personally have stopped using firefox after this, and stopped installing it on computers of friends and coworkers, so there must have been some small effect.
This was the missing hidden variable not explained in the narrative.
Firefox was previously significantly behind Chrome in the technical design, now it's getting better but there is still some lag.
And as explained in the article, this lag has been historically to a large degree caused by the extension model (need to keep backwards compatibility on a huge API surface, impossibility to introduce multi process architecture, need to always negotiate with extension devs on what can be changed and what not...).
There were two options:
1) specialize on power users with XUL extension but lag even more behind Chrome - leads quite certainly to drop of users, slide to irrelevancy and the eventual death
2) try to catch up with Chrome in technical design, but drop historical baggage, including XUL based addons - does not guarantee success but still provides at least hope
> ... and stopped installing it on computers of friends and coworkers, so there must have been some small effect.
It's sad to see people supporting monopoly this way ...
The realistic way to avoid monopolies and retain free-ish markets is to actively enforce anti-trust legislation. (And in the case of social media companies: force all players of a certain size to provide federation APIs, so people can leave the service and still talk to their friends and family.)
There will always be some people that try to avoid monopolies for ideological reasons; but 90% of the population won't care, they just want things to work and move on with their lives, and capturing that segment still makes you a monopoly.
Yes, I meant it more specifically that people here on HN who should know and should care are actively propagating and helping a monopoly. (these people often also have disproportionate influence)
When google controls the only remaining browser engine, it effectively controls web standards (or in other words, independent standard documents lose meaning since Blink is the standard).
Google is then free to push the web technologies in the direction which benefits mainly Google (think AMP) and which further tightens their grip on the web.
Ah yes, if you're reduced to power users your death is inevitable. Which is why Linux, of course, is a myth and does not exist.
Linux (as a kernel) is alive and thriving because of the server market not because of power users tweaking their bash powerlines.
It was exactly Quantum release which took away XUL extensions.
I agree that the number and power of WebExtension hooks is critical.
our brain is hard wired to respond to negative actions much stronger than positive ones. this comes from the not conscious part of the brain and it happens because it was much important in our early history to respond to threats, than it was to respond to good things.
consider this: how often have you stopped using a bank/restaurant/whatever else because they did something bad to you? how often have you switched just because somewhere was better, but not way better? a positive action has to be much much stronger in order to compete with a negative action.
Firefox had a unique, special power which differentiated it and Mozilla chose to kill it. No wonder its browser share dropped like a stone.
To talk on more specific terms, which XUL extension did you replace with Chrome App?
But I changed my browser to Chrome since Firefox lost its value proposition. It had a differentiating factor of superior experience and features that it chose to deliberately abandon.