This has never been the approach we've taken for any other virus. This sets a precedent that anyone who values privacy should be very, very against.
If you don't think these apps will be used
1) during wartime
2) to track political dissidents
3) to gather data on interactions between people in a country for things like 'urban planning'
4) as a monetized version of each of these
Then I don't think you're treating distributed, scalable contact tracing like other technology.