I have that!
> and all you will have achieved is replicating the user experience of bitcoin.
I've never used bitcoin or any other cryptocurrency. What's the user experience like?
I would describe the first-time-user onboarding procedure as "complex enough that it's unlikely to become mainstream"
Onboarding is elaborate to avoid fraud, but not really complicated, and basically a necessity if you don't want to have to go to a bank office to manage your account and make transactions.
Obviously, using government-controlled PKI for communications would be unwise, but there's very little risk to using government PKI for financial transactions as governments already have warrantless access to this data.
Even if you don't have to show government ID for every financial transaction, you need to show government ID (and, often, a lot more government paperwork) to open a financial account that can be used to make transactions. Your ability to move money is entirely predicated on the banks knowing who you are by linking your accounts to a tombstone government identity document.
Using PKI controlled by government to authenticate identity for transactions doesn't give government any more control over your affairs than it already has. All it does is add one more layer of authentication to the transaction process by allowing all parties involved to verify that their counterparty is the legal entity they claim to be.
Whereas the whole point of a public key system is that nobody needs your private key. So we don't need to provide individuals and businesses with a way to give their private key to somebody else. The only reason you'd give your private key to somebody else is because you want them to seamlessly impersonate you forever, so there's no need to make it any easier than, for example, giving your kidney to somebody else.
Concrete example: A WebAuthn/ U2F "Security Key" offers no way to get the Private Keys out. If you want to "steal" the credentials used to get into my GitHub your best bet is to somehow trick me into physically packaging up the USB authenticator itself and sending that to you by FedEx or something. Or maybe you could try putting a knife to my throat or something?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_identity_cards_in_the...
This also makes your next sentence nonsense, anyone advocating for PKI is advocating for a technology that has trusted authorities, that's how it works, it's as though you claimed computer evangelists don't like mathematics because it uses symbol manipulation.
And then it makes your next sentence nonsense, something like Signal isn't a PKI, it has no CA role, who "Janet" is on Signal is only a matter for you and Janet. Signal also isn't purely TOFU, you can insist on manually verifying every identity just as you can on SSH.
But even though I believe the Web PKI is the only successful public PKI there are plenty of other PKIs in use that are successful in a narrower sphere, and we're already in a discussion thread about such a sphere, the global banking system.
† The Web PKI isn't strictly just a PKI for the World Wide Web, it's actually a PKI for TLS services on the Public Internet. But it exists only because Netscape built SSL, and in practice its oversight is from the major browser vendors (most notably Mozilla but of course also Microsoft, Apple and Google). There was once a good chance the only TLS client implementation you had with any useful PKI enforcement was your web browser, today it's likely other tools on your system also do this... but always relying on the Web PKI.
It is a pretty secure system I think, but government procedures make it a pain to work with.