The syntax was again "ugly" but some people were so excited about the language that I had to look into it, which is when I learned why the syntax looks the way it does, and how powerful it is because it looks that way.
Needless to say, I felt monumentally stupid, not just for having done myself the disservice of not looking into lisps earlier, but for having the audacity to write things off out of "ewww" feelings. A perfect exhibit of programming being a pop culture and me being a mindless consumer.
Thankfully I learned my lesson, which came in handy when I came across Smalltalk. The syntax is powerful [0], and good luck getting that kind of power out of any conventional syntax language.
[0] among many other aspects.