I don't think so. We could win so much of the spam fight by just making signed messages mandatory. Would there still be some spam? Sure. But it's better than handing over all email to a few select companies.
It's the same problem with DDOS. Some providers tried to mail out letters "hey, your computer is involved in malicious things, please get it fixed", but that just lead to a lot more support requests that the ISPs can't handle. So we just accept that botnets are a thing.