100% open immigration from Western Europe, Canada, Australia, and similar countries... could possibly work.
100% open immigration to anybody who speaks fluent English... could possibly work.
But opening up our borders completely to Eastern Europe, Asia, South America, Africa would create complete chaos.
As an immigrant to the US from the former Soviet Union I know how hard it is to really learn the language, the culture, and assimilate to the point where you're actually leading a decent life and being a productive member of society.
It took my family about 4 years to really get situated and both of my parents are highly educated with a very strong work ethic and we had previous family living here.
And we had to be supported by welfare and other government programs for 3 of those years.
Although obviously a net gain over time, it takes a lot of resources to bring an immigrant into the American fold and we don't have enough of those resources to open our doors to everybody right now.
And it wouldn't even be good for the immigrants. With a large influx of people from their country coming in, most would probably just settle somewhere together, assimilate much slower and possibly even turn to semi-criminal activity like many Russian immigrants I knew in New York.
No, we need to change our immigration policy, but not just by opening up the doors.